Zealots and Tax Collectors: How Jesus Brought Opposites Together
When we read the names of the men Jesus chose as His apostles, we find Matthew, who worked at a tax office, and another disciple named Simon, whom Luke calls the Zealot. In a land ruled by Rome, collecting taxes and being known for zeal could suggest very different loyalties, although Scripture tells us much less about Simon’s past than it tells us about Matthew’s work. Jesus gave both men a place among the Twelve, the apostles He appointed to serve with Him and carry His message, and that meant their former associations could no longer decide whom they would obey.
Roman Taxes Made Political Allegiance Personal
For the people who encountered those men, taxes were one of the ways foreign rule reached into daily life. A family had to meet the demands placed on its produce or property, and a merchant could face customs charges or tolls while moving goods across a boundary or along a route. The person collecting the payment might be a local man, but he stood there on behalf of the authority requiring it. Resentment toward that authority could therefore be directed at the neighbor who collected its money.
The political arrangement was not identical everywhere Jesus traveled. Judea, the region that included Jerusalem, was governed directly by Rome during His ministry. Pontius Pilate served there as the Roman governor. Galilee, farther north, was ruled by Herod Antipas, whose local authority depended on Rome. Luke 3:1 names Pilate and Herod in their respective positions. A collector working under Galilee’s administration was not necessarily collecting the same kind of payment as the imperial tribute owed in Judea. I want to keep that distinction clear before treating every tax office in the Gospels as though it operated in exactly the same way.
There was also a question of faithfulness to God behind the political disagreement. Israel’s ancestors had been enslaved in Egypt under Pharaoh, the Egyptian king. God sent Moses to lead them out, and after His judgments upon Egypt, Pharaoh released them. God then gave Israel His Law and brought them toward the land He had promised. Later, He promised King David that his royal line and throne would be established before Him (Exodus 12:29-42; 2 Samuel 7:8-17).
By Jesus’ day, Rome exercised power over that land while honoring false gods. Some Jewish people cooperated with the authorities, others endured their demands, and some considered armed resistance an obligation to God. To understand why foreign rule could provoke that kind of response, we can look at what God had said about the king Israel was to choose. Moses gave these instructions before the people settled in the land.
“When you come to the land which the LORD your God is giving you, and possess it and dwell in it, and say, ‘I will set a king over me like all the nations that are around me,’ you shall surely set a king over you whom the LORD your God chooses; one from among your brethren you shall set as king over you; you may not set a foreigner over you, who is not your brother.”
The king was to be someone God chose from among Israel’s own people. As the passage continues, God also places limits on how that king could use his position. He was not to accumulate horses, wives, or great stores of silver and gold for himself. The warning about multiplying wives explicitly concerned the danger of his heart turning away from God. He was to write a copy of the Law and read it throughout his life, learning to fear the Lord and obey Him. Those instructions were meant to keep his heart from being lifted above his fellow Israelites. Being king placed him under a responsibility to God; it did not lift him above God’s commands.
I understand why someone living under Rome would take those words seriously. But the command about choosing an Israelite king does not, by itself, tell someone already living under conquest to refuse every payment or every form of public service. Other passages show faithful people living under foreign rulers while continuing to obey the Lord.
Daniel was one of the young men taken from Judah when Babylon’s king Nebuchadnezzar conquered Jerusalem. He and his companions were trained for service in the king’s government. Daniel was determined not to make himself unclean before God by eating the king’s food, so he sought permission for a different diet. He eventually entered the king’s service with the others (Daniel 1). His work in that government did not require him to acknowledge Babylon’s gods as his own. The distinction between serving a ruler and worshiping him became a matter of life and death later in Daniel’s account.
The prophet Jeremiah also wrote to people who had been carried away from Jerusalem to Babylon. He told them to build houses, plant gardens, raise their families, and seek the peace of the city where they were living. They were to pray to the Lord for it, because its peace would affect their own lives (Jeremiah 29:1-14). That instruction did not declare Babylon’s conquest or its false worship righteous. It told God’s people how to live while they remained there. They could seek the good of the place where they lived without surrendering their obedience to God.
Centuries later, Roman taxation brought the question of submission into open conflict. The census associated with the Roman official Quirinius in AD 6 included an assessment of property for taxation. Josephus, a first-century Jewish historian, describes the resistance in Antiquities 18. Judas the Galilean and a man named Zadok urged people to resist an assessment they regarded as a form of slavery. Josephus also says that Judas’s followers insisted that God alone was their ruler and lord.
Acts 5:37 recalls that same Judas rising during the census, drawing followers after him, and then perishing, after which his followers were scattered. The speaker there is Gamaliel, a respected teacher addressing the Jewish ruling council. He used the failed movement as an example when urging caution about attacking Jesus’ apostles. Judas the Galilean was an earlier leader of resistance, not Judas Iscariot, the disciple who betrayed Jesus.
None of that gives us a biography of Simon the Zealot. In Jewish War 4, Josephus uses the name Zealots for a violent faction in Jerusalem during the First Jewish War, the revolt against Rome that began decades after Jesus chose His apostles. His account describes attacks and murders within Jerusalem as rival groups fought for control. A claim to defend God’s rule did not make those acts righteous. But the conduct of that later faction cannot simply be assigned to Simon.
The evidence does not establish an uninterrupted organization connecting Judas’s followers, Simon, and the later Jerusalem faction. Zeal could describe intense religious devotion as well as a commitment to political resistance. Before deciding which associations lay behind Simon’s title, let’s look at what Luke actually records about Jesus choosing him.
Now it came to pass in those days that He went out to the mountain to pray, and continued all night in prayer to God. And when it was day, He called His disciples to Himself; and from them He chose twelve whom He also named apostles: Simon, whom He also named Peter, and Andrew his brother; James and John; Philip and Bartholomew; Matthew and Thomas; James the son of Alphaeus, and Simon called the Zealot; Judas the son of James, and Judas Iscariot who also became a traitor.
There are two men named Simon in this list. The first is the disciple Jesus also named Peter. The other is Simon called the Zealot. Matthew and Mark use the corresponding designation Cananaean, rendered “Cananite” in the NKJV and sometimes “Canaanite” in other English wording. It comes from an Aramaic term connected with zeal. That means the name does not establish that Simon belonged to the ancient Canaanite people.
Simon may have had nationalist or revolutionary associations, or he may have been known for religious zeal without belonging to an organized political party. The New Testament does not settle that question. It does not call him an assassin, describe a violent career, or record a conversation in which he renounced one. I do not want to turn a possible background into something Scripture says happened.
What Scripture does record is that Jesus prayed through the night and then selected these men from among His disciples. Simon and Matthew received their place through His choice. Acts 1:13 later names both men among the believers gathered in Jerusalem after the risen Jesus had ascended to Heaven. They continued together in prayer while waiting as He had instructed. Whatever had shaped their earlier lives, they were now serving under His authority.
Jesus Called Tax Collectors to Repentance, Not Respectability
Matthew’s occupation gives us firmer ground than speculation about Simon’s political past. The Gospel describes him sitting at a tax office when Jesus called him. The Greek word used for tax collectors, telonai, can include people collecting customs and tolls. Their duties and the arrangements under which they worked varied, so the older English word publican should not make us picture every local collector as a wealthy Roman contractor. The man at the office might be collecting on behalf of someone else, but he still dealt directly with people required to pay.
That position created opportunities for abuse. A collector could demand more money than was due or use the authority behind him to intimidate someone who objected. Taking money through threats or the misuse of power is extortion. The harm caused by those practices, together with resentment toward the rulers receiving the revenue, helps explain why tax collectors so often appear alongside people publicly regarded as sinners in the Gospels.
I would not accuse every individual collector of every abuse associated with his occupation. At the same time, dishonest collection caused real losses, and repentance had to reach the way a collector treated the people in front of him. John the Baptist addressed that directly. John was preaching near the Jordan River to prepare people for Jesus, calling them to turn from sin and be baptized. When his hearers asked what repentance should look like, collectors and soldiers asked about their own conduct.
Then tax collectors also came to be baptized, and said to him, “Teacher, what shall we do?” And he said to them, “Collect no more than what is appointed for you.” Likewise the soldiers asked him, saying, “And what shall we do?” So he said to them, “Do not intimidate anyone or accuse falsely, and be content with your wages.”
John gave the collectors a clear limit: they were to take only the amount appointed. He did not tell every collector that he must resign. His answer allowed for honest work, while requiring an end to demands the collector had no right to make. A person could not claim to have turned to God and then deliberately keep using his office to take someone else’s money.
The soldiers received a related correction. They were to stop intimidating people and making false accusations, and they were to be content with their wages. Someone facing an armed man might have little immediate protection against a threat. John required the soldier’s repentance to change that encounter, rather than leaving another person under the same pressure while the soldier claimed to have become religious.
I find that to be a useful way of examining the use of authority. It is easy to speak about repentance in general while leaving a particular dishonest practice untouched. John named the conduct that needed to stop. Honest records, fair demands, and restraint would not buy forgiveness, but they would show that turning to God was changing how these men used their positions.
Matthew received a further call to leave his office and follow Jesus personally. Matthew 9 places the encounter after Jesus had healed a paralyzed man and declared His authority to forgive sins. As He went on from there, He saw Matthew at his work. His occupation as a collector did not keep Jesus from inviting him to follow.
As Jesus passed on from there, He saw a man named Matthew sitting at the tax office. And He said to him, “Follow Me.” So he arose and followed Him. Now it happened, as Jesus sat at the table in the house, that behold, many tax collectors and sinners came and sat down with Him and His disciples. And when the Pharisees saw it, they said to His disciples, “Why does your Teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?” When Jesus heard that, He said to them, “Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick. But go and learn what this means: ‘I desire mercy and not sacrifice.’ For I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners, to repentance.”
Matthew got up and followed Him. Mark 2:13-17 and Luke 5:27-32 call the man Levi, and I understand their parallel accounts to describe this same disciple. Luke tells us that he left all, and it also tells us that Levi prepared a large feast in his house. That supplies details beyond Matthew’s shorter account without making Luke’s wording something Matthew himself wrote.
The meal brought many tax collectors and others identified as sinners into Jesus’ company. Pharisees, members of a Jewish religious movement concerned with interpreting and observing the Law, objected to His eating with them. Jesus answered their complaint with the comparison of a physician and sick people. A doctor goes where help is needed. The sinners at that table needed the One who could call them to repentance and forgive them.
His reference to mercy came from Hosea 6:6. Through that prophet, God had rebuked people whose faithfulness disappeared like morning dew. They could offer sacrifices while failing to show the mercy and knowledge of God He required. By directing the Pharisees to that passage, Jesus exposed what was missing from their complaint. Keeping away from these sinners would not help them turn to God. Jesus had come to call them, and His presence among them did not mean He approved of the sins from which they needed to turn.
Matthew therefore did not have to repair his reputation until he deserved an invitation from Christ. Jesus called him where he was. Once he followed, however, his money and his dealings with people belonged under the authority of his new Lord. Leaving the tax office could not become an excuse to avoid obedience in the rest of his life.
Later, Luke 19 shows that same mercy reaching another collector’s wealth. Jesus entered Jericho, where Zacchaeus was a rich chief tax collector. Zacchaeus wanted to see Him, but he was short and could not see past the crowd. He ran ahead and climbed a sycamore tree along the way Jesus was taking. When Jesus reached the place, He looked up, called Zacchaeus by name, and told him to come down because He would stay at his house that day.
Zacchaeus hurried down and received Him joyfully. The people watching complained that Jesus had gone to be the guest of a sinner. Zacchaeus then spoke about what he would do with his wealth.
Then Zacchaeus stood and said to the Lord, “Look, Lord, I give half of my goods to the poor; and if I have taken anything from anyone by false accusation, I restore fourfold.” And Jesus said to him, “Today salvation has come to this house, because he also is a son of Abraham; for the Son of Man has come to seek and to save that which was lost.”
He declared that he would give half his goods to the poor and repay four times what he had taken from anyone by false accusation. The offer was concrete. It concerned people in need and anyone he had defrauded, and carrying it out would place a substantial part of his wealth at their service. Jesus announced that salvation had come to the house and described His own mission as seeking and saving the lost.
I understand Zacchaeus’s response as the fruit of receiving Christ, rather than a price paid for forgiveness. When Jesus called him a son of Abraham, He was receiving a man whom the crowd had treated as an outsider because of his conduct and occupation. Abraham was the ancestor to whom God had made His covenant promises, but ancestry alone could not excuse fraud. The welcome of Christ brought this man to an answer about what he would do with his wealth.
That keeps me from treating grace as permission to hold on to the proceeds of sin. Someone who has defrauded another person should address the loss he caused as far as he can. Repayment cannot cleanse his guilt before God, but the need for forgiveness does not erase the injury done to his neighbor. The complete study on Zacchaeus examines his declaration and the restitution laws in greater detail. Here, we can already see that Christ’s mercy reached into the use of his money.
Matthew and Simon Came Under One Greater Lord
Matthew’s response helps us understand what it meant for him to stand beside Simon among the Twelve. Jesus had not simply gathered people with different labels and asked them to tolerate one another. He called them to follow Him. Their shared service depended on His authority, so neither could make a former loyalty the final judge of what he ought to do.
That does not give me permission to invent a quarrel between them. Scripture never describes Matthew and Simon arguing over Rome, nor does it give us a private scene in which they reconciled their politics. Their names in the apostolic lists establish that Jesus chose them to serve together. The possible tension between a collector and a man known for zeal helps us think about that calling, but it remains a possible tension, not a recorded dispute.
Both men were still accountable to their Lord. Collecting revenue could never make exploitation righteous, and zeal for a cause could never make a sinful method acceptable. Those are implications of Christ’s authority over His disciples, rather than accusations Scripture makes against Matthew or Simon. Their backgrounds might explain how they had once viewed other people, but their obedience now had to be governed by what Jesus taught.
I think the same responsibility reaches disagreements within the church. We should examine a policy honestly and oppose what Scripture condemns. But a label from the political left or right cannot tell me whether someone has been born again. Another believer may need correction, and I may need it too. If I refuse to hear Scripture because it challenges a loyalty I want to protect, my strong convictions have become a barrier to obedience. Fellowship does not require hiding sin or surrendering truth; it requires both of us to remain answerable to Christ.
Jesus addressed the question of competing loyalties directly during His final week in Jerusalem. Matthew 22 says the Pharisees planned to trap Him through His words. They sent their disciples with the Herodians, people associated with support for Herod’s ruling house. These groups did not have identical interests, but they cooperated in trying to obtain an answer they could use against Him.
They began by praising His honesty and His refusal to favor people because of their position. Then they asked whether paying taxes to Caesar was lawful. Caesar was the Roman emperor, so the question concerned the revenue claimed by the foreign ruler over their land. The word kensos refers here to imperial tribute, commonly described as a poll tax, a tax assessed on individuals. It was a more specific question than whether every kind of charge collected at every local office was permissible.
If Jesus approved the payment, His opponents could portray Him as accepting pagan domination. If He rejected it, they could accuse Him before the Roman authorities. Luke 20:20 explicitly says the questioners wanted to seize on His words and deliver Him to the governor. Jesus understood the trap and had them produce a denarius, the coin used for the payment.
“Tell us, therefore, what do You think? Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, or not?” But Jesus perceived their wickedness, and said, “Why do you test Me, you hypocrites? Show Me the tax money.” So they brought Him a denarius. And He said to them, “Whose image and inscription is this?” They said to Him, “Caesar’s.” And He said to them, “Render therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” When they had heard these words, they marveled, and left Him and went their way.
He first made them identify whose image and inscription the coin carried. They recognized Caesar’s. Jesus then told them to give Caesar what was due to him and to give God what was due to God. The verb translated render, apodidomi, can express giving back, repaying, or paying what is owed. His answer recognized a real civil obligation while leaving God’s claim over the person intact.
Paying with the emperor’s currency did not make the emperor righteous, and it did not require worshiping the man whose image was stamped on it. Caesar could receive a tax without receiving the allegiance that belonged to God alone. Jesus’ answer therefore refused the assumption that meeting a civil obligation must amount to surrendering one’s faith.
Some teachers connect the image on that coin with the image of God in humanity. I find that to be a useful application when we make clear where it comes from. Genesis 1:26-27 says that God created mankind in His image, male and female. Jesus did not ask His questioners whose image was on them, so I would not present that familiar application as an additional sentence He spoke. But the Genesis passage does help us explain why a ruler cannot own the person who pays him.
A coin could be handed over to settle a debt. The person handing it over still belonged to God, whose authority reached his worship, conscience, and conduct. An emperor could not become the final authority on good and evil merely because he possessed the power to enforce his demands. He too depended on God for life and remained accountable to Him. That gives us a reason to take civil duties seriously while recognizing that their claim has a limit.
Civil Authority Is Real, but Its Claim Has a Boundary
Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ, explained those duties to believers living under Roman government. In Romans 12, he had told them to live peaceably as far as it depended on them and to leave vengeance to God. He then addressed the authority of government in Romans 13. These Christians were not told to wait until the rulers shared their faith before taking their obligations seriously.
Let every soul be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and the authorities that exist are appointed by God. Therefore whoever resists the authority resists the ordinance of God, and those who resist will bring judgment on themselves. For rulers are not a terror to good works, but to evil. Do you want to be unafraid of the authority? Do what is good, and you will have praise from the same. For he is God’s minister to you for good. But if you do evil, be afraid; for he does not bear the sword in vain; for he is God’s minister, an avenger to execute wrath on him who practices evil. Therefore you must be subject, not only because of wrath but also for conscience’ sake. For because of this you also pay taxes, for they are God’s ministers attending continually to this very thing. Render therefore to all their due: taxes to whom taxes are due, customs to whom customs, fear to whom fear, honor to whom honor.
Paul describes civil authority as a responsibility held under God. The ruler is to restrain wrongdoing and serve the good of the people he governs. The sword represents real authority to use force against evildoers. That responsibility is different from a private person taking revenge, which Paul had just forbidden in the preceding chapter.
Because the office exists under God, the person holding it remains accountable to Him. Calling a ruler God’s servant does not mean every decision he makes is righteous. Pilate’s treatment of Jesus alone prevents us from reading the passage that way: he knew Jesus was innocent and still delivered Him to be crucified. An official can misuse the authority entrusted to him, and that misuse remains sin. Paul is explaining what government is responsible to do, rather than promising that every government will do it faithfully.
His command to pay what is owed nevertheless reaches people who dislike the official receiving it. Resentment does not make a dishonest return truthful or turn money I owe into money I may keep. Peter makes a similar distinction in 1 Peter 2:13-17 when he tells believers to submit for the Lord’s sake, honor the king, and fear God. Proper respect for a ruler remains beneath the reverence and final obedience owed to the Lord.
I therefore cannot treat paying a tax as though it means I approve of every use of public money. Jesus did not require His hearers to approve of Caesar’s conduct before making the payment He recognized. I can object to wrongdoing and seek change while still being responsible for honesty in my own dealings.
In a complicated tax system, that includes keeping truthful records and getting qualified help when I do not understand an obligation. A lawful challenge to an improper demand is different from concealing information or making a false statement. Complaints about waste do not authorize fraud, and corruption by a public official does not remove my own responsibility before God. I can pursue reform through honest means without pretending that the system is already just in every respect.
The boundary becomes clear when a human authority commands something that directly conflicts with obedience to God. The apostles faced that conflict after Jesus’ resurrection. He had commissioned them to bear witness to Him, and they continued teaching in Jerusalem despite opposition from the Jewish ruling council. Acts 5 describes their arrest and imprisonment, followed by an angel opening the prison and directing them to return to the temple and speak to the people.
They returned and taught. The officials who expected to find them in custody learned that they were standing in the temple again, and the captain and officers brought them before the council. The high priest, the leader of the priests who served at the temple, then confronted them about the very teaching they had been commanded to give.
And when they had brought them, they set them before the council. And the high priest asked them, saying, “Did we not strictly command you not to teach in this name? And look, you have filled Jerusalem with your doctrine, and intend to bring this Man’s blood on us!” But Peter and the other apostles answered and said: “We ought to obey God rather than men.”
Peter and the other apostles were facing two commands they could not both obey. Christ had sent them to testify, while the council demanded that they stop speaking in His name. Their answer identified whose authority must prevail. They continued preaching, even after they were beaten and again ordered to stop. Their refusal concerned the demand that required disobedience to Christ; it did not cancel every other responsibility they had toward people in authority.
Daniel’s companions had faced a similar conflict centuries earlier. These were the men who had entered Babylon’s service with him, known there as Shadrach, Meshach, and Abed-Nego. In Daniel 3, King Nebuchadnezzar erected a gold image and ordered the people gathered for its dedication to fall down and worship when the music sounded. Anyone who refused would be thrown into a burning furnace. The command required those men to give an image the worship they owed to God.
They refused, and when the king threatened them personally, they said that God was able to deliver them. They also made clear that even if He did not deliver them, they would not worship the image. The king had them thrown into the furnace, but God preserved them, and they came out unharmed. Their faithfulness did not depend on receiving a promise that refusing the king would be painless. They had identified a demand they could not obey without sinning.
Later, under King Darius, Daniel himself held a high position in government. Other officials tried to find misconduct they could use against him, but his work was faithful. They therefore arranged a decree aimed at his worship: for thirty days, petitions could be made to no god or man except the king, on pain of being thrown to the lions. When Daniel knew the decree had been signed, he continued praying to God as he had done before (Daniel 6).
Daniel was cast into the lions’ den, and God sent His angel to shut their mouths. When the king came the next morning, Daniel could answer him alive. The account preserves both his refusal and the faithful service that had left his accusers unable to find ordinary misconduct. He had not used devotion to God as a reason to become dishonest in office. He continued to do good while refusing the particular command that denied him obedience to the Lord.
Before I appeal to those examples, I need to be able to explain the actual conflict with Scripture. Disliking a policy does not put me in Daniel’s position, and claiming that God told me something cannot justify fraud, vengeance, or unlawful violence. Conscience is the inward judgment that tells me I am answerable for what I do, but it needs to be instructed by God’s Word. A strong impulse is not proof that God has authorized it.
When obeying a human command would require sin, I must refuse it, even if refusal brings a cost. Honest appeals may be available, and I can use them. If punishment follows, enduring it does not require me to call it just. Daniel and the apostles show people giving God the obedience that was His while continuing to act faithfully toward others. Their examples leave no excuse for treating every civil office with contempt.
Christ’s Kingdom Does Not Advance Through Worldly Force
The charge brought against Jesus before Pilate shows how His teaching about authority could be deliberately distorted. This happened before the resurrection and the apostles’ preaching we have just considered. Jesus had been arrested, taken before the Jewish council, and questioned about whether He was the Christ, God’s promised King. The leaders then brought Him to Pilate, the Roman governor we met earlier, and framed their accusation as a threat to Roman rule.
Then the whole multitude of them arose and led Him to Pilate. And they began to accuse Him, saying, “We found this fellow perverting the nation, and forbidding to pay taxes to Caesar, saying that He Himself is Christ, a King.” Then Pilate asked Him, saying, “Are You the King of the Jews?” He answered him and said, “It is as you say.” So Pilate said to the chief priests and the crowd, “I find no fault in this Man.”
They accused Him of forbidding payment to Caesar even though He had taught people to give Caesar what was due. They joined that false allegation to something true: He was Christ the King. Presenting Him as a ruler who opposed Rome’s revenue gave their charge a political form that Pilate would have to consider. It did not make the accusation honest.
Pilate initially declared that he found no fault in Him. John’s account takes us into the questioning and records Jesus explaining what kind of kingdom He possessed. The governor was asking whether Jesus was King of the Jews, and Jesus answered without denying His kingship or promising an armed uprising.
Jesus answered, “My kingdom is not of this world. If My kingdom were of this world, My servants would fight, so that I should not be delivered to the Jews; but now My kingdom is not from here.” Pilate therefore said to Him, “Are You a king then?” Jesus answered, “You say rightly that I am a king. For this cause I was born, and for this cause I have come into the world, that I should bear witness to the truth. Everyone who is of the truth hears My voice.” Pilate said to Him, “What is truth?” And when he had said this, he went out again to the Jews, and said to them, “I find no fault in Him at all.
I understand Jesus’ statement that His kingdom was not of this world to describe its source and character. It did not arise from the rebellious order in which rulers gained and defended power. He was not saying that He lacked authority over the earth or would never reign here. He explained the difference by pointing to what His servants would have done if His kingdom had belonged to that worldly order: they would have fought to prevent His being handed over.
Earlier that night, when the arresting party came to the garden, Simon Peter had drawn a sword and struck the high priest’s servant, cutting off his right ear. John identifies that servant as Malchus. Jesus told Peter to put the sword away, and Luke records that He healed the injured man (John 18:10-11; Luke 22:50-51). This was Simon Peter, not Simon the Zealot. We do have an account of a disciple using a weapon, but we must not transfer it to the man whose title sounds more political.
Jesus willingly went forward to His death, and before Pilate He bore witness to the truth. The governor’s ability to order an execution did not make him the judge of what was ultimately true. Those who belonged to the truth would hear Christ’s voice. Pilate declared Him innocent again, yet later yielded to the demand for crucifixion. His failure shows why recognizing civil authority must never become a claim that the official exercising it is always righteous.
Christ’s submission to that death does not mean He surrendered His future reign. After His resurrection, the apostles watched Him ascend, and they were told that this same Jesus would return as they had seen Him go (Acts 1:9-11). Revelation 19 describes Him coming as King of kings and Lord of lords, and Revelation 20 describes His thousand-year reign. I understand those passages to teach His bodily return and reign as King. The church does not bring that reign into being by seizing power in His name.
Jesus gave His followers a different task. In Matthew 28:18-20, the risen Lord commissioned them to make disciples, baptize them, and teach them to obey everything He had commanded. Before ascending, He promised that the Holy Spirit would empower them to be His witnesses (Acts 1:8). Their work depended on proclaiming His message and teaching people to follow Him.
Prayer, service, and biblical discipline belong to that work. Discipline means the church must also address sin among its members according to Scripture, rather than treating every profession of faith as permission to continue in wrongdoing. But taking control of an institution or killing an opponent cannot make anyone believe. A person needs to hear the gospel, turn to Christ in repentance and faith, and receive the new life God gives. Force cannot produce that response.
Civil government has the responsibility we saw in Romans 13 to restrain evildoers, including the authority to use force. That does not make armed conquest the church’s commission. Christians may consider questions of public policy and civil duty within biblical limits, but they must distinguish those responsibilities from the work of making disciples. The biblical study on war and fighting examines those questions more fully.
The false accusation against Jesus also makes me examine how I speak about opponents. If I am exposing real corruption, I must describe it truthfully. Anger cannot turn an invented allegation into a fact. A just cause does not authorize unlawful threats or the cultivation of hatred toward the people involved. Jesus’ accusers did not become honest because they believed their goal justified what they were saying.
At the same time, I need to live so that an accusation of fraud or lawless violence does not become true of me. If I conceal income or accept a bribe, another official’s misconduct cannot excuse my own. Speaking truthfully about wrongdoing and living honestly are obligations I can fulfill together. Neither requires me to flatter government or remain silent about its failures.
Believers can disagree about a tax rate, a budget, or a proposed reform without disagreeing about the gospel. Each proposal still deserves examination by the evidence and by biblical principles. Where voting, petitions, and appeals are available, we can use them to oppose exploitation and seek responsible government. Those opportunities allow us to pursue change while remaining accountable for the means we use.
We can also help people who have been mistreated and pray for rulers without approving their wrongdoing. Those are concrete ways to care for neighbors whose lives are affected by public decisions. My allegiance to Christ continues to govern me when I enter public debate, just as it governs the money I handle privately. That responsibility is part of what the study on ambassadors of Christ explains: a person representing Christ must remain subject to the Lord he represents.
The Gospel Gives Us a Greater Allegiance
Even a needed political reform cannot reconcile a sinner to God. Reconciliation means that the hostility caused by sin is dealt with and the person is brought into a right relationship with Him. That is the need beneath both the dishonesty of an abusive collector and any sinful methods used by a zealous opponent of the government. Neither person’s usefulness to a cause can remove his guilt.
Paul explains the peace Christ gives in Ephesians 2. He first reminds his readers that salvation is God’s gift, received through faith rather than earned by works. He then addresses Gentiles, people who were not Jews. Before coming to Christ, they had been outside Israel’s covenant privileges, without the hope those promises supplied. Paul describes how Christ’s blood brought them near and joined believing Jews and Gentiles in one body.
But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off have been brought near by the blood of Christ. For He Himself is our peace, who has made both one, and has broken down the middle wall of separation, having abolished in His flesh the enmity, that is, the law of commandments contained in ordinances, so as to create in Himself one new man from the two, thus making peace, and that He might reconcile them both to God in one body through the cross, thereby putting to death the enmity. And He came and preached peace to you who were afar off and to those who were near. For through Him we both have access by one Spirit to the Father.
The two groups in this passage are Jews and Gentiles. Matthew and Simon were both Jewish, so Paul is not describing their particular differences. I want to keep the passage’s actual subject clear before applying it. Gentiles who believed were no longer outsiders to God’s household. Through Christ, both Jewish and Gentile believers had access to the Father by the same Holy Spirit.
Paul describes their former separation as a wall and the hostility as something Christ put to death through the cross. The Law’s commandments and ordinances had distinguished Israel from the nations, but they could not supply a separate way for either group to earn acceptance with God. Christ reconciled both to Him in one body. As Paul continues, he describes them as members of one household, built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets with Jesus Christ as the chief cornerstone. Their place together depends on Him.
I believe that gives us a sound basis for addressing former hostility among believers, even when their disagreement was about a different matter. If Christ has received both of us, I cannot insist that my brother remain outside the fellowship merely because his former associations offend me. That does not remove the need for correction or establish that every past practice was acceptable. It means our shared standing before God rests on the same Savior.
The peace Paul describes was accomplished through Christ’s blood because every person has sinned and needs forgiveness. Jesus is the eternal Son of God. John 1 identifies Him as the Word who was with God and was God, and it also tells us that He became flesh. He became fully man without ceasing to be fully God. Luke 1 records that His mother Mary was a virgin and that His conception was the work of the Holy Spirit. He entered human life without sharing our sin.
His sinless perfection made Him the perfect sacrifice, and He voluntarily gave Himself to be slain for us. John 10:17-18 records His authority to lay down His life and take it again. The torture and death inflicted by wicked men were real, but they did not make Him a helpless victim whose mission had failed. His shed blood and death completed His saving sacrifice before His burial, and He then rose bodily from the grave.
I do not understand that sacrifice as the Father punishing, cursing, abandoning, striking, bruising, or pouring wrath upon Jesus. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit acted in unity to redeem us. Before His arrest, Jesus told His disciples that they would scatter and leave Him alone, yet He would not be alone because the Father was with Him (John 16:32). The redemption He accomplished did not require the Father to turn against His beloved Son.
Christ died for the sins of the whole world, so God’s offer of salvation is genuine for every person (1 John 2:1-2). People can resist and reject Him, but those who repent and believe receive forgiveness and are justified, declared righteous before God. Their acceptance rests on what Christ has completed. The respectability of a job, the intensity of a conviction, or the willingness to give money away cannot provide another basis for it.
The person who believes is born again, receiving spiritual life from God. Paul also explains that believers are indwelt and sealed by the Holy Spirit, whose presence guarantees the inheritance God has promised (Ephesians 1:13-14; 2:22). They are secure in the eternal life He gives. Obedience grows from that new life, and it neither earns salvation nor keeps a person saved. A shallow profession is no substitute for genuine repentance and faith, although genuine believers still have sins to confess and forsake.
That is why Matthew’s departure from the tax office could not itself save him, Simon’s zeal could not save him, and Zacchaeus’s repayment could not buy forgiveness. Christ saves, and His people learn to obey Him with the money and influence entrusted to them. Someone who has profited from corruption is not beyond His mercy, nor is someone whose resistance to corruption has itself become sinful.
Both must come to the same Lord in repentance and faith. Once He has received them, neither has grounds to demand that the other remain an outsider because of his past alone. Their fellowship can grow as they learn to submit to Christ’s truth and accept the correction each needs. That shared obedience gives them something stronger than agreement about every public question.
My Final Thoughts
Jesus gave Matthew and Simon a place among His apostles, and their shared calling placed both under His authority. Scripture does not give us a private political dispute between them, but it does show us the Lord they followed receiving repentant collectors, recognizing what was owed to Caesar, and reserving for God the obedience no ruler could claim. His mercy received sinners and required their conduct to come under His rule.
I want that allegiance to govern my own use of money and influence. It means paying what I owe, speaking truthfully when I oppose wrongdoing, and refusing a command that would require me to sin. It also means receiving a fellow believer whom Christ has received, even when his former loyalties differ from mine. The Lord who forgives us is also the One we serve together, and I remain answerable to Him in the way I treat that person.