Killing and Murder: What Is the Biblical Difference?
A man dies because his neighbor attacks him, and another man dies because an axe head comes loose while two neighbors are cutting wood. Both deaths leave someone grieving, but Scripture does not judge the two men who caused those deaths in the same way. I think we can understand the command against murder much more clearly when we look at why God required judgment in one case and protection for the man who caused the death in the other.
What the Sixth Commandment Forbids
God gave the Ten Commandments to Israel after He brought the people out of slavery in Egypt under the leadership of Moses. At Mount Sinai, He told them how they were to honor Him and how they were to treat one another. Among those commands was this prohibition:
“You shall not murder.”
Many people are familiar with the King James wording, “Thou shalt not kill.” Read by itself in modern English, that can sound as though every action that causes a death violates the command. The NKJV uses “murder,” and the laws that follow help us see why. The same God who prohibited murder also told Israel to punish a murderer and to protect someone who had unintentionally caused a death. He was distinguishing those actions, not contradicting Himself.
The Hebrew wording of Exodus 20:13 is lo ratsach. The verb ratsach appears elsewhere in passages about a deliberate murderer, but it is also used for the person who kills unintentionally. We can see both uses in Numbers 35, and the Brown-Driver-Briggs Hebrew lexicon records them. That means we cannot decide whether a man was guilty simply by finding this Hebrew word in the account. We have to read what happened and what God said should be done about it.
Other Hebrew words also describe acts that cause death. Harag can mean to kill or slay, nakah describes striking, including a blow that kills, and forms of muth describe dying or being put to death. Those words help us understand the action, but none gives a person permission to kill merely because he prefers one description over another. Calling a killing defense or calling the person who did it a soldier does not establish that it was right.
Look at the commands around the prohibition of murder in Exodus 20:12–17. God tells His people to honor their parents, and He forbids adultery, theft, false witness, and coveting what belongs to a neighbor. The neighbor is someone I must learn to treat according to God’s will. I cannot take his life because he has something I want, because he has offended me, or because I think I would be better off without him.
Jesus and the apostles continue to teach that murder is sin. The church has not been commissioned to enforce every civil penalty that God gave national Israel, but that does not release Christians from His command to love their neighbors. In Romans 13:8–10, Paul includes the prohibition of murder when he explains what that love requires. The reason human life must be protected reaches even further back than Israel’s law.
After the flood, God spoke to Noah and his sons, whose descendants would fill the earth. His words about human bloodshed were therefore not a privilege belonging only to Israel:
Surely for your lifeblood I will demand a reckoning; from the hand of every beast I will require it, and from the hand of man. From the hand of every man’s brother I will require the life of man. “Whoever sheds man’s blood, By man his blood shall be shed; For in the image of God He made man.”
God grounds His demand for an account in the fact that He made human beings in His image. Our lives have worth because of our relationship to the Creator who made us to represent Him. That does not mean God has a human body or that His image is a claim about our physical resemblance to Him. It means I am dealing with someone whose dignity God has given, and I do not have the authority to cancel it.
A person does not gain that dignity by becoming strong, useful, healthy, or independent. A weak person has the same claim to protection as someone who can defend himself. Even a person guilty of a crime remains a human being made in God’s image, which is why punishment must be governed by justice rather than by the desire to make him suffer. Government did not create the worth of the people under its authority, and it answers to God for what it does to them.
We can see God’s concern for a victim before we ever reach the flood. Cain and Abel were sons of Adam and Eve. Cain worked the ground, and Abel kept sheep. When they brought offerings to the LORD, He accepted Abel and his offering, but He did not accept Cain and his offering. Cain became angry, and God spoke to him before he acted on that anger.
So the LORD said to Cain, “Why are you angry? And why has your countenance fallen? If you do well, will you not be accepted? And if you do not do well, sin lies at the door. And its desire is for you, but you should rule over it.” Now Cain talked with Abel his brother; and it came to pass, when they were in the field, that Cain rose up against Abel his brother and killed him. Then the LORD said to Cain, “Where is Abel your brother?” He said, “I do not know. Am I my brother’s keeper?” And He said, “What have you done? The voice of your brother’s blood cries out to Me from the ground.”
Cain had been warned. God told him that sin was seeking to master him and that he was responsible to rule over it. Yet when the brothers were in the field, Cain rose against Abel and killed him. Afterward, he answered God’s question with a lie and then questioned whether caring for his brother was his responsibility. God already knew where Abel was and what Cain had done. The blood of the man Cain had silenced was not hidden from Him.
God pronounced judgment on Cain, but He also placed a mark on him so that other people would not kill him in retaliation. Genesis 4:11–16 does not describe what that mark looked like. It does tell us what it was intended to prevent. Cain’s guilt did not give everyone who encountered him permission to carry out a death sentence. I think that helps us recognize how easily a justified condemnation of murder can become an excuse for private revenge.
Intent, Accident, and Responsibility
The laws after the Ten Commandments give Israel specific cases to judge. In Exodus 21, God distinguishes a fatal assault from a death that occurred without the person lying in wait. He provides a place of refuge for one, while insisting that a man who deliberately kills his neighbor must face judgment.
“He who strikes a man so that he dies shall surely be put to death. However, if he did not lie in wait, but God delivered him into his hand, then I will appoint for you a place where he may flee. “But if a man acts with premeditation against his neighbor, to kill him by treachery, you shall take him from My altar, that he may die.”
The altar was the place where sacrifices were offered to God. A man could not commit a treacherous killing and then use that sacred place to shield himself from the consequences. God told Israel to take him even from His altar. Religious surroundings did not turn his act into something other than murder.
Numbers 35:16–21 explains further what those judging a death should consider. It describes attacks made with iron, a stone capable of killing, and a wooden weapon capable of killing. It also describes hatred, ambush, and a person striking his neighbor out of hostility. The manner of the attack had to be considered along with what the accused said about his intentions. A person who deliberately struck someone with a deadly weapon could not make the evidence disappear by insisting afterward that he never meant for the victim to die.
Responsibility also reaches beyond the person holding the weapon. David, Israel’s king, slept with Bathsheba while her husband Uriah was serving in his army. When she told David she was pregnant, he summoned Uriah from the fighting and tried to send him home to his wife. I understand David’s purpose to have been to conceal the adultery by making the pregnancy appear to be the result of Uriah’s visit. But Uriah would not enjoy the comforts of home while the other men were living in the field. Even after David made him drunk, he did not go home.
David then sent a letter to Joab, the commander of his army, instructing him to place Uriah where the fighting was most dangerous and withdraw from him so that he would die. Uriah carried that letter himself. Joab placed him where strong enemy fighters were positioned, and Uriah was killed along with other men. Later, God sent the prophet Nathan to confront David and specifically charged the king with killing Uriah by the sword of the Ammonites. David had not swung that sword, but he had arranged for it to kill the man whose wife he had taken (2 Samuel 11; 12:1–9).
A later king, Ahab, wanted the vineyard of a man named Naboth because it was near his palace. Naboth would not surrender his family’s inheritance, and Ahab went home angry. Ahab’s wife Jezebel then wrote letters in the king’s name telling the local leaders to arrange false accusations against Naboth. Two men accused him of blaspheming God and the king, and the people took him outside the city and stoned him to death. Ahab then went to take possession of the vineyard.
God sent Elijah, His prophet, to confront Ahab there. The accusation in 1 Kings 21 was murder and the taking of Naboth’s property. Jezebel had arranged the testimony, the officials had carried out her instructions, and Ahab took the benefit. Having witnesses and a public proceeding did not make any of it just. The proceeding itself had been used to kill an innocent man.
Now compare those deliberate actions with the example Moses gives in Deuteronomy 19. Two neighbors go into the woods to cut timber. As one man swings his axe at a tree, the head comes off the handle and strikes the other man.
“And this is the case of the manslayer who flees there, that he may live: Whoever kills his neighbor unintentionally, not having hated him in time past– as when a man goes to the woods with his neighbor to cut timber, and his hand swings a stroke with the ax to cut down the tree, and the head slips from the handle and strikes his neighbor so that he dies–he shall flee to one of these cities and live; lest the avenger of blood, while his anger is hot, pursue the manslayer and overtake him, because the way is long, and kill him, though he was not deserving of death, since he had not hated the victim in time past.”
The man holding the axe caused his neighbor’s death, but God expressly says he was not deserving of death. He had not gone into the woods to attack an enemy. The loss was real, and the victim’s family had reason to grieve, but their grief could not turn the surviving man into a murderer.
The “avenger of blood” was a family representative who had a recognized role when a relative was killed. Numbers 35 assigned him a role in executing a murderer, but it also required the accused to receive a hearing. Because the avenger’s anger could lead him to kill before the circumstances were judged, God told Israel to set aside cities where the accused could find refuge. Moses even told the people to prepare the roads and arrange access to those cities. Protection had to be something the man could actually reach, rather than a provision that existed only in words (Deuteronomy 19:1–7).
That protection for an accident does not mean a person can ignore a known danger. Exodus 21:28–29 describes an ox that gores someone to death. If the animal had been known to gore and its owner had been warned but failed to confine it, God held the owner responsible. He had not personally struck the victim, but he had allowed a danger he knew about to remain. Saying he did not want a death would not answer the question of why he had done nothing to prevent it.
Deuteronomy 22:8 requires a person building a house to put a parapet around the roof. A parapet is a protective barrier that helps keep someone from falling. God connected failure to provide it with bloodguilt, which means responsibility for bloodshed. Caring about another person’s life includes doing what I reasonably can to prevent a danger before anyone is hurt.
I can apply that principle to the way I drive, the way I store a weapon or medication, or whether I leave a dangerous machine where a child can reach it. People who depend on my care should not be exposed to a known danger because taking precautions would inconvenience me. At the same time, a terrible outcome does not prove that someone was negligent. We have to establish what the person could reasonably have known and what he was responsible to do. God does not tell us to find someone to blame merely because we are grieving.
Numbers 35 explains how the city of refuge protected that distinction. Reaching the city did not end the inquiry. It allowed the accused to live long enough for the case to be heard:
However, if he pushes him suddenly without enmity, or throws anything at him without lying in wait, or uses a stone, by which a man could die, throwing it at him without seeing him, so that he dies, while he was not his enemy or seeking his harm, then the congregation shall judge between the manslayer and the avenger of blood according to these judgments. So the congregation shall deliver the manslayer from the hand of the avenger of blood, and the congregation shall return him to the city of refuge where he had fled, and he shall remain there until the death of the high priest who was anointed with the holy oil.
The congregation was to judge between the manslayer, meaning the person who caused the death, and the avenger of blood. If the circumstances were as the passage describes, they were to deliver him from the avenger and return him to the city of refuge. Someone who deliberately murdered his neighbor could not obtain the same protection simply by running to the same place. Deuteronomy 19:11–13 required the elders to bring such a man out for judgment.
Even the man found to have killed unintentionally had to remain within the city until the death of the high priest, Israel’s chief priest. Numbers 35:26–28 says he would be exposed to the avenger if he went outside those limits. After the high priest died, he could return to his own land. The death had lasting consequences without being judged as a deliberate murder.
The same chapter forbids accepting money to let a murderer escape his sentence. It also forbids accepting money to let the unintentional manslayer return home before the appointed time. Wealth could not buy a person a different judgment. And before a murderer could be put to death, there had to be more than one witness. One person’s accusation was not sufficient grounds for taking the accused person’s life (Numbers 35:30–32).
I understand these provisions to restrain the cycle in which one family answers a death with another death and the violence continues. The accusation had to be examined, the people judging it had to distinguish the cases, and the person entitled to protection had to receive it. Neither a furious relative nor a confident official was a substitute for truthful evidence.
The church is not being told to establish cities of refuge or reproduce every part of Israel’s national legal system. Modern legal categories also differ from those ancient provisions. But I should care about the justice God required: protection from a mob, a fair opportunity to answer an accusation, and a judgment that fits what has actually been established. Naboth’s death shows why the appearance of a proper hearing is not enough. If witnesses lie and officials cooperate with them, the court itself can become an instrument of murder.
Defense, Vengeance, and Civil Justice
A person may also cause a death while responding to an intruder. Exodus 22 considers a thief breaking in, and it distinguishes what happens in darkness from what happens after sunrise.
If the thief is found breaking in, and he is struck so that he dies, there shall be no guilt for his bloodshed. If the sun has risen on him, there shall be guilt for his bloodshed. He should make full restitution; if he has nothing, then he shall be sold for his theft.
The passage says there was no bloodguilt when the thief was killed during the nighttime break-in, but there was guilt after the sun had risen. It does not explain every reason for that distinction. I think the darkness helps explain why the danger would be judged differently. Someone awakened by an intruder at night may not be able to tell what the intruder intends or how much danger the household faces. Daylight changes what can be seen and assessed.
Notice also what the law requires for theft. The thief was to make restitution, which means he had to repay what he owed for the wrong. If he had nothing, the law provided for his sale for the theft. The stealing of property itself was not treated here as a capital offense, an offense punishable by death. I cannot use this passage as permission to kill simply because someone has taken something that belongs to me.
I believe the passage supports defending life against a genuine, immediate threat while also requiring limits on the force used. The purpose is to stop the danger. If a safe escape removes the people at risk from that danger, I believe it should be taken. If restraint or lesser force will stop an attack without exposing an innocent person to greater danger, there is no justification for using greater force merely because I am angry.
Those are judgments that may have to be made in frightening circumstances with very little time. I would be careful about speaking as though someone facing an emergency had every option plainly in front of him. But fear cannot make every action right. Once an attacker is no longer a threat, continuing to attack him is no longer necessary to preserve life. The force used must be proportionate to the danger being stopped.
That is also why I distinguish defense from vengeance. Defense responds to a present danger; vengeance seeks to make someone pay for what he has done. Paul addresses the second desire when he writes to the Christians in Rome:
Repay no one evil for evil. Have regard for good things in the sight of all men. If it is possible, as much as depends on you, live peaceably with all men. Beloved, do not avenge yourselves, but rather give place to wrath; for it is written, “Vengeance is Mine, I will repay,” says the Lord. Therefore “If your enemy is hungry, feed him; If he is thirsty, give him a drink; For in so doing you will heap coals of fire on his head.” Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.
Paul does not tell me that my enemy’s wrongdoing was acceptable. He tells me what I am to do with the desire to repay it. I am to leave vengeance with God and, if that enemy is hungry or thirsty, provide what he needs. The passage gives me an act of kindness to do when I might prefer to dwell on how I could hurt him.
The reference to coals of fire does not turn that kindness into a hidden method of revenge. Paul’s instruction is to overcome evil with good. I cannot obey it while treating a meal as another way to enjoy my enemy’s pain. I can desire his repentance and leave judgment with the Lord even when what he did has brought lasting harm.
Living peaceably is qualified by what is possible and what depends on us. A victim is not required to conceal a crime, remain within an abuser’s reach, or make a dangerous person feel trusted. Reporting violence and seeking protection allow those charged with public justice to do their work. Forgiveness does not require pretending that the injury was small, and restoring trust takes more than an offender demanding that everyone move on.
Paul continues into the responsibility of governing authorities in Romans 13. Read beside his prohibition of personal vengeance, his description of the ruler helps us see why refusing revenge does not mean abandoning public justice.
For rulers are not a terror to good works, but to evil. Do you want to be unafraid of the authority? Do what is good, and you will have praise from the same. For he is God’s minister to you for good. But if you do evil, be afraid; for he does not bear the sword in vain; for he is God’s minister, an avenger to execute wrath on him who practices evil.
The ruler is described as God’s servant for the good of the people and as an avenger against wrongdoing. The sword signifies real authority to restrain and punish evil. I understand that to include the authority to impose death in a proper case. The church, acting as the church, has not been given the civil sword, and a private person cannot take it upon himself to become the judge and executioner of those he considers guilty.
A ruler also remains accountable to the God whose servant he is supposed to be. Romans 13 does not turn every order from an official into a righteous command. When the apostles, whom Jesus had appointed to bear witness to Him, were ordered by the Jewish ruling council in Jerusalem to stop teaching in His name, they continued to obey God. Acts 5:17–32 describes their arrest, their release by an angel, and their return to teaching before they were brought back before the council. They had a command from Christ that no human authority could cancel.
I came to my conclusion about capital punishment by comparing Genesis 9 with the law concerning murder and Paul’s words about the civil sword. God requires an account for the taking of human life, He prescribed death for proven murder in Israel, and He recognizes the authority of rulers to punish evil. I therefore believe that a proper public authority may impose capital punishment for proven murder. Taking a life under that authority is not automatically the same moral act as the murder being punished.
Because a sentence of death cannot be undone, the responsibility to establish guilt is grave. A rushed hearing, dishonest testimony, prejudice, or unequal enforcement does not become acceptable because the charge is serious. If there is reasonable uncertainty about the person’s guilt, execution should not proceed. The permission to punish does not give an official permission to be cruel or careless with someone’s life.
Recognizing that authority also requires us to examine whether a particular court or proceeding is exercising it justly. I can uphold the biblical authority for capital punishment and still object to an execution supported by unreliable evidence. Christians who agree on that authority may reach different conclusions about whether a particular system or case meets the demands of justice. The answer has to come from the facts of the case, rather than from an assumption that every official decision deserves our approval.
If an offender truly repents, I should welcome his turning to Christ and may seek mercy for him. His forgiveness before God does not automatically erase what he owes to the people he injured or the sentence imposed for his crime. Someone can be reconciled to God and still face restitution, imprisonment, or a just sentence of death. Mercy does not depend on pretending the offense never happened.
War, Canaan, and Unjust Orders
The authority of government also raises the question of warfare. Scripture records battles God approved and campaigns He commanded, but it also records rulers acting out of pride and rebellion. The fact that a nation sent an army does not settle whether the cause was just. To understand Israel’s conquest of Canaan, we have to begin with the particular command God gave that nation.
Near the end of Moses’ life, the people were preparing to cross the Jordan River and enter Canaan, the land God had promised to their ancestors. Moses told them what the LORD required concerning the nations living there:
“When the LORD your God brings you into the land which you go to possess, and has cast out many nations before you, the Hittites and the Girgashites and the Amorites and the Canaanites and the Perizzites and the Hivites and the Jebusites, seven nations greater and mightier than you, and when the LORD your God delivers them over to you, you shall conquer them and utterly destroy them. You shall make no covenant with them nor show mercy to them.”
Those are severe words, and I understand them as a command of divine judgment. God had already spoken to Abraham, Israel’s ancestor, about the land centuries before. In Genesis 15:12–21, He told Abraham that his descendants would live under oppression in another country and would later return. He connected the delay with the fact that the iniquity of the Amorites, one of the peoples in that land, was not yet complete. Israel’s arrival was tied to God’s appointed judgment as well as His promise.
Moses also warned Israel against thinking that receiving the land proved their own moral superiority. Deuteronomy 9:1–6 says that the nations were being driven out because of their wickedness and that God was keeping His promise to Abraham, his son Isaac, and Isaac’s son Jacob. Israel was a stubborn people who also owed Him obedience. They could not take a command about a particular land and turn it into permission to seize whatever territory they wanted.
God is the giver of life and the righteous Judge. His direction to Moses and to Joshua, who led Israel after Moses, concerned particular people, a particular place, and an appointed time. A modern ruler cannot supply that commission for himself by announcing that God supports his military ambitions. Claiming God’s name does not turn aggression into obedience or remove responsibility for innocent deaths.
The commission Jesus gave His church makes the difference plain. After He rose from the dead, He sent His disciples to make disciples of the nations, baptize them, and teach them to obey His commands (Matthew 28:16–20). He did not send them to take land or put people to death for refusing to believe. The church spreads the gospel by bearing witness to Christ, including when doing so brings suffering upon the witnesses.
For ordinary warfare, I draw principles from Scripture’s teaching about justice and our responsibility to our neighbors. There must be a just cause, such as defending people from wrongful attack, and responsible public authority must direct the action. The force used must fit the danger being addressed, and soldiers must distinguish those fighting from civilians who are not taking part. A just peace should be the aim, rather than conquest for its own sake or revenge against an entire population. These are conclusions I draw from the Bible’s wider teaching, rather than a list quoted from one verse.
I do not understand the command to love our enemies as abolishing the civil sword Paul describes. I also do not understand that sword as permission to enjoy violence. A Christian considering military service has to take both the duty to protect others and the command to seek peace seriously. Some believers conclude that they should not participate in war, a position usually called pacifism. I disagree with making every use of armed force a violation of the command against murder, while recognizing the need to treat a fellow believer’s sincere conscience with care.
Whether a person is a soldier or a civilian, obeying an order never removes his responsibility to God. Exodus 1 gives us a direct example. Pharaoh, the king of Egypt, feared the growing number of Israelites living in his country. He ordered the Hebrew midwives Shiphrah and Puah to kill the boys born to Hebrew women while letting the girls live. The midwives feared God and preserved the boys’ lives. Pharaoh’s position did not make his murderous command righteous.
We see another refusal in 1 Samuel 22. Saul, Israel’s king before David, was pursuing David. During his flight, David received food and a sword from Ahimelech, a priest at Nob. David had told the priest that he was on the king’s business, and Ahimelech did not know of the supposed conspiracy Saul later accused him of joining.
When Doeg, one of Saul’s servants, reported that Ahimelech had helped David, Saul summoned the priests and condemned them. His guards refused his order to kill the LORD’s priests. Saul then gave the order to Doeg, who killed eighty-five priests and also attacked their city, including its women and children. The guards’ refusal and Doeg’s compliance stand beside one another in the same account. The command came from the same king, but obeying it meant participating in his wickedness.
A soldier, officer, or other official remains responsible for the part he takes in an action. Being ordered to target innocent people, torture prisoners, manufacture evidence, or cover up an atrocity does not make it right to do so. Refusing may cost a person his position, reputation, or even his safety. I believe the church should be prepared to help people who bear those costs because they will not disobey God.
Protecting Innocent and Vulnerable Life
The innocent person who needs protection is not always someone who can speak for himself. A child in the womb is already a human being, and his dependence on his mother does not make him less worthy of care. David speaks in Psalm 139:13–16 of God forming him in his mother’s womb. The person praising God is speaking of himself before birth, when his body was still being formed.
I believe that intentionally ending an innocent child’s life through elective abortion violates the command against murder. Neither the child’s size nor whether someone wants him determines his worth. Disability does not remove it either. The study on abortion develops the biblical reasoning in more detail, but the principle here follows from what we have already seen: human dignity comes from God, and another person’s dependence does not give us authority to destroy him.
When conception follows rape or incest, the crime must be faced honestly. The child is not the offender, and the mother must not be blamed for the violence done to her. She needs protection from the person who harmed her, compassionate care, and people willing to help with the burdens she now faces. Defending the child’s life must never become an excuse to disregard hers.
Medical emergencies also require an honest understanding of what is happening. Treatment directed toward saving life in an already dangerous situation must be distinguished from directly intending a child’s death. A general label cannot tell us the purpose or effect of every procedure. Qualified clinicians need to assess the actual condition and the available treatment, while those making decisions seek to preserve life rather than treat either patient as expendable.
I cannot claim to care about a mother and her child while refusing to consider what they need after I have stated my position. She may need safe housing, food, medical care, or practical help caring for the baby. The father should accept his responsibility rather than pressure her to end the pregnancy. Families and churches can help carry those needs instead of leaving a frightened woman to face them alone. The study on the sanctity of life explains further why vulnerability calls for protection.
That responsibility continues when a person is suffering so deeply that he wants his own life to end. I believe suicide is a grave wrong because the life being taken still belongs to someone made in God’s image. But I cannot perfectly judge another person’s mental capacity or how responsible he was for his actions in a particular case. God knows circumstances that I do not. A person in that distress needs to be heard and helped, not dismissed as though explaining a command has relieved his suffering.
If someone is in immediate danger of taking his life, take what he says seriously and seek urgent professional help. Stay with him if it is safe, contact emergency or crisis professionals, and help reduce access to an immediate means of harm when that can be done safely. The National Institute of Mental Health emphasizes listening, helping the person remain safe, connecting him with help, and staying in contact afterward. Prayer and pastoral care belong alongside that practical help.
The care of someone who is dying also calls for a distinction between relieving suffering and deliberately causing death. Euthanasia intentionally brings about a person’s death in order to end suffering. Pain relief is not automatically euthanasia, and neither is accepting that an illness has reached a point where a treatment will no longer provide reasonable benefit. A person may decline an excessively burdensome treatment while continuing to receive care and comfort.
To judge such a decision, I need to know what the treatment is intended to do, whether it is likely to help, and what burden it will place on the patient. The question is not whether the patient has become less valuable. His worth remains even when his condition cannot be cured. The decision concerns what care is appropriate for someone whose life we still value.
A do-not-resuscitate order, commonly called a DNR, addresses one specific intervention. It tells clinicians not to attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation, or CPR, when the patient’s heart or breathing stops. CPR is an attempt to restore circulation and breathing. A DNR does not itself direct clinicians to stop pain relief, other medicines, or nutrition. Deciding against CPR is therefore not automatically a decision to cause death. The patient and those caring for him should discuss its likely benefits and burdens with the treating clinicians.
When recovery is no longer possible, the person still needs relief from pain, truthful counsel, prayer, and people willing to remain with him. He must also be protected from the idea that his continued existence is an inconvenience to everyone else. I want the person receiving care to know that he is still wanted. Helping him through the dying process is very different from deciding that it would be better to end his life.
Jesus Brings the Command into the Heart
After considering what other people may or may not do, I also have to let Jesus address what is happening in me. In the Sermon on the Mount, He speaks to people who know the prohibition of murder and then exposes anger and contempt that they might excuse because they have never physically killed anyone.
“You have heard that it was said to those of old, ‘You shall not murder, and whoever murders will be in danger of the judgment.’ But I say to you that whoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment. And whoever says to his brother, ‘Raca!’ shall be in danger of the council. But whoever says, ‘You fool!’ shall be in danger of hell fire. Therefore if you bring your gift to the altar, and there remember that your brother has something against you, leave your gift there before the altar, and go your way. First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift.”
Jesus does not allow me to measure my righteousness only by whether I have physically killed someone. If I despise someone and use my words to treat him as worthless, there is already sin in my heart. “Raca” was a contemptuous insult, expressing the idea of an empty-headed or worthless person. Jesus’ warning reaches the attitude toward the person, rather than merely forbidding a particular sound or expression.
The NKJV includes “without a cause” in Matthew 5:22. Those words are also present in the Textus Receptus, the received Greek text underlying the King James New Testament. Scripture recognizes that there can be righteous anger. Mark 3:1–6, for example, describes Jesus in a synagogue, a Jewish place of worship, with a man whose hand was withered. Men were watching to see whether He would heal on the Sabbath so that they could accuse Him. Jesus looked at them with anger and grieved over the hardness of their hearts before healing the man.
His anger was not a sinful desire to harm the person in front of Him. He healed the man while grieving over those who were looking for an accusation against Him. My anger does not become righteous merely because I can explain what set it off. A real wrong can be followed by my own pride, hatred, and desire to humiliate the person who wronged me. I have to judge that response too.
Jesus then describes a worshiper bringing an offering to the altar and remembering that his brother has something against him. He tells the worshiper to go and seek reconciliation before returning with the gift. I cannot use an outward act of devotion to avoid acknowledging the harm I have done. If I have lied about someone, spoken cruelly, or treated him unjustly, confessing that wrong and repairing what I can belongs to obedience to God.
Reconciliation still has to deal with the truth. It cannot be forced by demanding that a victim trust someone who continues to harm him. I can put away revenge and pursue peace while maintaining necessary boundaries. And if I am the offender, I cannot use this passage to make the person I injured responsible for restoring a relationship while I refuse to change.
Jesus is exposing guilt before God. He is not instructing a civil court to give an angry person the same sentence as someone who has carried out a murder. The actual injuries differ, and the law itself requires those differences to be judged. But sinful anger does not become morally innocent simply because it has not yet produced the outward act.
John, one of Jesus’ apostles, develops the same concern in his first letter. He returns to Cain and says Cain’s works were evil while Abel’s were righteous. That hatred of his brother led to the murder we read about in Genesis. John then contrasts that hatred with the life and love believers have received in Christ:
We know that we have passed from death to life, because we love the brethren. He who does not love his brother abides in death. Whoever hates his brother is a murderer, and you know that no murderer has eternal life abiding in him. By this we know love, because He laid down His life for us. And we also ought to lay down our lives for the brethren. But whoever has this world’s goods, and sees his brother in need, and shuts up his heart from him, how does the love of God abide in him? My little children, let us not love in word or in tongue, but in deed and in truth.
Calling the hater a murderer identifies the moral character of his hatred. It does not give a court authority to treat an inward attitude as proof that someone committed a physical killing. John is asking whether a person’s claim to belong to Christ is being contradicted by the way he regards other believers. A settled life of hatred cannot be defended as the fruit of new life in Him.
Then John moves into a need that may be right in front of us. Someone has enough possessions to help a brother, sees that brother’s need, and closes his heart against him. Words about love cannot make that refusal loving. Christ gave His life for us, and the love He teaches calls me to give of what I have for another person’s good. My time and possessions are part of that response, not matters separate from it.
The warning about hatred is severe, but it does not mean that someone with bloodshed in his past is beyond mercy. Scripture records God’s work in people whose lives included terrible wrongdoing. We should read each account honestly rather than treating every death as the same offense or minimizing what happened because God later used the person.
Moses, before he led Israel out of Egypt, saw an Egyptian beating a Hebrew man. Moses looked around, killed the Egyptian, and hid his body in the sand. When the act became known and Pharaoh sought to kill him, Moses fled to Midian (Exodus 2:11–15). God later called Moses to lead His people, but that later calling does not erase the earlier account or make it a general permission to kill in any situation we regard as unjust.
David’s guilt over Uriah is directly stated. When Nathan confronted him, David confessed that he had sinned against the LORD, and Nathan told him that God had put away his sin. The consequences for David’s household remained painful and severe (2 Samuel 12:10–15). Forgiveness did not require God to describe Uriah’s death as an accident.
Paul also had to face what he had done before becoming an apostle. Acts first introduces him under the name Saul, a different man from Israel’s King Saul. He approved of the death of Stephen, a believer who was stoned after bearing witness to Jesus, and he then helped imprison Christian men and women. While traveling to Damascus to continue that persecution, he was confronted by the risen Jesus. The man who had opposed Christ began preaching that Jesus is the Son of God (Acts 7:54–60; 8:1–4; 9:1–22).
When Paul later describes the mercy he received in 1 Timothy 1:12–17, he does not excuse his former violence. He identifies himself as a former persecutor and explains that Christ’s patience toward him shows others that they can believe in Him for everlasting life. I find that to be a reason to speak honestly about sin while still offering hope to the person who is willing to turn to the Savior.
Even a murderer can receive complete forgiveness through repentance and faith in Jesus Christ. That forgiveness does not require a court to cancel a just sentence, and it does not require a victim’s family to trust the offender immediately. A person who professes faith cannot use grace to hide evidence, continue abuse, or demand silence from the people he injured. Turning from sin includes bringing the truth into the open and accepting responsibility for what he has done.
The Savior to whom he turns is the eternal Son of God, fully God and fully man, who lived without sin. Wicked men tortured and killed Jesus, yet He willingly gave Himself as the perfect sacrifice for our sins. His atonement rests on His perfection and His voluntary offering of Himself to be slain. His saving sacrifice through His shed blood and death was complete before His burial and bodily resurrection. His resurrection is essential to the gospel, as Paul explains in 1 Corinthians 15:1–22.
I do not understand the cross as the Father punishing, cursing, abandoning, striking, bruising, or pouring wrath on the Son. Before His arrest, Jesus said that the Father was with Him even though His disciples would leave Him. Hebrews describes Him offering Himself without spot to God through the eternal Spirit (John 16:32; Hebrews 9:14). Father, Son, and Holy Spirit acted in perfect unity to accomplish our redemption. Christ’s willingness to give His life does not excuse the wickedness of those who killed Him.
He died for the whole world, and God’s offer of salvation is genuine for every person, though people can resist and reject Him. The person who repents and believes in Jesus is forgiven and justified, meaning that God declares him righteous. He is born again, given new spiritual life by God, and the Holy Spirit comes to dwell in him permanently and seals him for redemption. That seal marks him as belonging to God and guarantees the inheritance God has promised (Ephesians 1:13–14).
I believe the person who is truly born again is eternally secure in Christ. Jesus promises His sheep eternal life and says that they will never perish (John 10:27–30). That promise does not make a Christian label proof of new birth or turn lawlessness into acceptable conduct. New life produces a changed response to God and to other people, even though that growth is not sinless perfection. Obedience neither earns salvation nor keeps a believer saved. It is the fruit of the life God has given (Ephesians 2:8–10).
A repentant believer may still have consequences to face and damage that he cannot fully repair. Those realities do not put him beyond Christ’s saving mercy. They give him responsibilities to meet honestly as someone who has received it. The related studies on the sanctity of life, abortion, and the Law examine further how these truths bear on protecting life and obeying God.
My Final Thoughts
The Bible distinguishes murder from other acts that cause death because God judges what people actually do. He holds the murderer responsible, protects the person who caused a death unintentionally, and calls an owner to account for leaving a known danger unrestrained. He also gives public authorities a responsibility that I cannot simply claim for myself. Those distinctions serve justice only when we apply them honestly.
I cannot use them to defend violence I favor while refusing to examine my own anger. Jesus brings the command into my heart, and His example calls me to care for the people whose lives God has placed near mine. I want that care to be visible in the way I protect the vulnerable, refuse revenge, and take responsibility when I have done wrong. Where sin has already brought harm, the answer is to tell the truth, turn to Christ for mercy, and begin doing what that mercy calls me to do.