Wicked Schemes: What Makes a Plan Sinful?
A plan can be carefully thought out and still be wicked. If I arrange things so that someone will believe a lie, lose what belongs to him, or be unable to defend himself, being organized does not make what I am doing right. I think the question we have to ask is both what I am trying to accomplish and what I am willing to do to accomplish it.
That leaves plenty of room for good planning. Families have responsibilities to prepare for, work requires decisions, and ministry often depends on people making arrangements together. Proverbs 20:18 commends counsel in establishing plans, and Proverbs 21:5 connects diligent planning with provision. The problem begins when I use that ability to prepare for something God has forbidden, or when I decide that a worthwhile goal gives me permission to deceive or mistreat someone along the way.
When Planning Becomes Wicked Scheming
Suppose several people agree to make a false accusation. They can divide up the work, decide who will speak first, and make sure their accounts sound alike. Their agreement has not made the accusation true. It has simply made the lie more difficult for someone else to recognize. The same is true of stealing. A plan that gets property into my hands without anyone noticing may be effective, but its success does not change whose property it was.
I also cannot excuse a sinful method by pointing to something good that eventually happened. Joseph’s brothers sold him to traders who took him to Egypt, and then they used his bloodied coat to lead their father to believe that a wild animal had killed him. Years later, Joseph held authority in Egypt and was able to provide food for his family during a famine. When he spoke to his brothers about what they had done, he said that they had intended evil against him, while God had intended good through what happened. The preservation of the family did not turn their betrayal into obedience. We can read that sequence in Genesis 37:17–36, 45:1–15, and 50:15–21.
At the same time, I do not want us to mistake every private conversation for a wicked scheme. A family may need to discuss a sensitive matter without involving everyone they know. Doctors and pastors have reasons to protect confidences, and people arranging protection may need to keep details away from someone who could cause harm. Privacy can serve a good purpose. What needs examining is whether someone is using it to protect another person or to conceal wrongdoing and prevent the truth from being tested.
God knows the purpose behind a plan even when the person making it keeps that purpose hidden. I do not have that knowledge of someone else’s heart. That means I have to take actual wrongdoing seriously while being careful about what I claim to know. A study about deceit should make me more truthful in my own accusations, because a false accusation can itself become part of the harm Scripture condemns.
To see how deception works, let’s begin with the account of Adam and his wife Eve in the garden of Eden. God had allowed Adam to eat from the trees of the garden, but He had forbidden eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and had warned him of death. In Genesis 3 the serpent questioned God’s command when speaking to Eve. He then directly contradicted the warning and presented disobedience as a way to gain something desirable.
Then the serpent said to the woman, "You will not surely die. For God knows that in the day you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil." So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree desirable to make one wise, she took of its fruit and ate. She also gave to her husband with her, and he ate.
Their eyes were opened after they ate, but look at what followed. Adam and Eve recognized their nakedness, made coverings for themselves, and hid when they heard God in the garden. Adam explained that he was afraid. The serpent had held out the prospect of becoming like God while denying the death God had warned about. The account ends with them driven from the garden, and God’s words to Adam include his eventual return to the dust from which he had been made.
I think that helps us recognize why a deception can contain something true and still be a deception. The serpent’s promise about opened eyes did not make his denial of death truthful. In our own dealings, a person may select accurate details while leaving out the facts that would change the listener’s understanding. If I do that deliberately so that someone reaches a false conclusion, I cannot excuse myself by saying that the individual details I mentioned were correct.
That is also why pressure deserves examination. Someone may flatter a person until he trusts advice he otherwise would question, or insist that there is no time to check a claim before making a decision. A threat can be used in much the same way, making a person afraid to ask for help. There are real emergencies that require quick decisions, so urgency alone does not establish deceit. But when urgency is being manufactured to keep the truth from being examined, it has become part of the plan.
Scripture brings the planning itself under God’s judgment. In Proverbs 6:12–15, the wicked man uses his mouth, gestures, and movements while continually devising evil and stirring up discord. The next verses name the things the LORD hates, including the heart where such plans are formed.
These six things the LORD hates, Yes, seven are an abomination to Him: A proud look, A lying tongue, Hands that shed innocent blood, A heart that devises wicked plans, Feet that are swift in running to evil, A false witness who speaks lies, And one who sows discord among brethren.
The movement from six things to seven is a form of Hebrew numerical saying. The first number prepares us for the second, and the list then names seven things. The NET Bible’s note on the numerical pattern explains that this arrangement does not make the list exhaustive. These are not the only sins God hates. The passage brings us through several connected ways people do harm and ends with someone sowing discord among brethren.
Notice how much of a person is involved. A heart devises the plan, a tongue tells the lie, and feet hurry to carry out the evil. Hands may shed innocent blood, while a false witness helps someone escape responsibility or brings judgment on an innocent person. I understand God’s hatred here as His righteous opposition to the evil and the injury it causes. He is not having an unpredictable outburst. He is telling us plainly what He condemns.
Some sins happen in a sudden response to fear or anger. They still need to be confessed, but a deliberate scheme involves another step: the person gives thought to how the wrong can be accomplished. Psalm 36 describes someone who has reached the point of flattering himself instead of fearing God. That self-flattery helps explain why he continues planning rather than turning away from what he is doing.
An oracle within my heart concerning the transgression of the wicked: There is no fear of God before his eyes. For he flatters himself in his own eyes, When he finds out his iniquity and when he hates. The words of his mouth are wickedness and deceit; He has ceased to be wise and to do good. He devises wickedness on his bed; He sets himself in a way that is not good; He does not abhor evil.
He is lying on his bed devising wickedness, and then he sets himself on the course he has chosen. This is more than a conversation that came out badly. His deceitful speech belongs to a purpose he is willing to pursue. I find that to be a searching description, because it asks what I am doing with my thoughts before anyone else can see the result.
The psalm does not leave us looking only at that man. David goes on to describe God’s mercy and faithfulness, His righteousness and judgments, and the refuge people find under His care. He then asks to be protected from the proud and wicked. The evil is real, but it has not changed who God is or made Him unable to preserve those who come to Him. That gives us somewhere to turn when we encounter deliberate harm, and it also gives us reason to stop when we recognize that kind of planning in ourselves.
How Schemes Exploit Weakness and Power
A person arranging harm often chooses someone he thinks will have difficulty resisting or being believed. Psalm 10 describes the wicked watching for the helpless, much as a hunter watches for an animal that can be caught. The comparison makes us consider the intention behind the waiting. He is looking for an opportunity to take advantage of someone.
He sits in the lurking places of the villages; In the secret places he murders the innocent; His eyes are secretly fixed on the helpless. He lies in wait secretly, as a lion in his den; He lies in wait to catch the poor; He catches the poor when he draws him into his net. So he crouches, he lies low, That the helpless may fall by his strength. He has said in his heart, "God has forgotten; He hides His face; He will never see."
The poor person’s weakness becomes useful to the one setting the trap. That may involve physical strength, but money and position can also give someone an advantage. A person without resources may struggle to challenge a dishonest claim. Someone who does not understand the language being used may not know what he is agreeing to. A person with no witnesses may fear that nobody will listen to him. Those difficulties should move us to help establish what happened, rather than make it easier to dismiss him.
The wicked man in the psalm also assumes that God will not see or require an account. Yet the prayer that follows says that God has seen the trouble and grief, and it appeals to Him as the helper of the fatherless. By the end of the psalm, the LORD is identified as King forever, hearing the humble and bringing justice to the oppressed. The person who seems powerless before an influential man has not become invisible to God.
That ought to affect how a church, family, or institution responds when someone reports harm. A respected title does not answer an accusation. The report needs to be heard, relevant evidence needs to be preserved, and the person raising the concern must not be punished simply for asking for help. Careful examination protects against false accusations as well as hidden wrongdoing, because it requires us to deal with what actually happened.
False witness is particularly destructive because it interferes with that examination. Someone may coach another person to repeat a claim, alter a record, or present only the part of a conversation that supports a desired result. Even a person who was not involved in the original plan can spread the injury by repeating a damaging report without checking it. Before I pass something along, I need to know whether I am helping the truth become known or simply giving a rumor another voice.
Discord can grow through the same process. A person speaks privately to several people, tells each one what the others supposedly meant, and gradually teaches them to hear hostility in ordinary words. Before anyone has spoken directly about the facts, friendships have begun to break apart. Making peace in that situation requires truth. It does not mean calling abuse a personality conflict or pressuring an injured person to restore access to someone who remains dangerous.
Micah gives us an example of planning backed by enough power to carry it out. He ministered during the eighth century BC, in the reigns of Jotham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah, kings of Judah. His prophecy addressed the sins of God’s covenant people, including the way powerful people treated the households around them. In Micah 2, the land and houses they wanted belonged to other families.
Woe to those who devise iniquity, And work out evil on their beds! At morning light they practice it, Because it is in the power of their hand. They covet fields and take them by violence, Also houses, and seize them. So they oppress a man and his house, A man and his inheritance. Therefore thus says the LORD: "Behold, against this family I am devising disaster, From which you cannot remove your necks; Nor shall you walk haughtily, For this is an evil time."
Pay attention to the order. They work out the evil while they are on their beds, and at morning light they put it into practice because they have the power to do it. Their desire for someone else’s field has become a plan to take it. The result is that a household loses its home and inheritance. In Israel, the family’s inherited land was also bound up with its place among God’s covenant people and its means of living. These were people being driven from what belonged to them.
God answered their plans by announcing disaster against them. The ability to seize property had made them confident, but it had not put them beyond His judgment. I think that is something to remember whenever an unfair arrangement has impressive paperwork behind it. A signature or an official position does not make oppression righteous. We still have to ask whether the people involved are being treated truthfully and justly.
Micah 2 also ends with God’s promise to gather the remnant of Israel, with their king going before them and the LORD at their head. The chapter therefore contains both judgment on the oppressors and a future for the people God would gather. I do not read His patience as approval of the powerful, or His judgment as the cancellation of His promises to Israel.
In Esther, a personal grievance grew into a plan against an entire people. Haman was an official whom King Ahasuerus had promoted in the Persian Empire. Mordecai was a Jew who would not bow before him. Haman became furious, and when he learned who Mordecai’s people were, he decided to seek the destruction of all the Jews in the kingdom. Esther 3 lets us see the distance between the offense he took and the enormous harm he planned.
Haman did not tell the king that he wanted to destroy a people because one man would not bow to him. He described them as a scattered people with different laws who did not keep the king’s laws, and he offered a large sum of money in connection with their destruction. The king gave him authority to issue a decree. Letters went throughout the empire ordering the killing of the Jews, including women and children, and the plundering of their possessions on an appointed day.
Esther, the queen, was herself Jewish, and Mordecai was her cousin who had raised her as his own daughter after her parents died. He sent her information about the decree and urged her to plead with the king for her people. Approaching the king without being summoned could cost her life unless he extended his scepter to receive her, so her decision to go involved a real risk. She asked Mordecai to gather the Jews in the city to fast for her, and she and her maids would fast too.
When Esther went before the king, he extended the scepter and received her. She invited him and Haman to a banquet, and there she asked them to return for another banquet the next day. At that second gathering, she explained that her request concerned her own life and the lives of her people. Haman was present to hear her name him as the man responsible.
Then Queen Esther answered and said, "If I have found favor in your sight, O king, and if it pleases the king, let my life be given me at my petition, and my people at my request. For we have been sold, my people and I, to be destroyed, to be killed, and to be annihilated. Had we been sold as male and female slaves, I would have held my tongue, although the enemy could never compensate for the king's loss." So King Ahasuerus answered and said to Queen Esther, "Who is he, and where is he, who would dare presume in his heart to do such a thing?" And Esther said, "The adversary and enemy is this wicked Haman!" So Haman was terrified before the king and queen.
The people Haman had described as a problem to eliminate included the queen standing before the king. Esther made that connection plain and named the man responsible. Later in the same chapter, Harbonah, one of the king’s eunuchs, pointed out the gallows Haman had prepared for Mordecai. The king ordered Haman to be hanged on the very gallows he had intended for the man he hated.
Haman’s death did not automatically remove the danger created by his decree. Esther pleaded again for her people in chapter 8, and a further decree authorized the Jews to gather and defend their lives. I think that part of the account helps us see why exposing a schemer may be only part of protecting the people he has threatened. What he set in motion may still need to be addressed.
Daniel faced another kind of attack through royal authority. He was serving as one of three governors under Darius, with officials beneath them accounting for the kingdom’s affairs. The king was considering placing Daniel over the whole realm. Other officials tried to find a fault in his work, but Daniel was faithful and they could find no charge against him. They then decided that their opportunity would have to involve his obedience to God.
So these governors and satraps thronged before the king, and said thus to him: "King Darius, live forever! All the governors of the kingdom, the administrators and satraps, the counselors and advisors, have consulted together to establish a royal statute and to make a firm decree, that whoever petitions any god or man for thirty days, except you, O king, shall be cast into the den of lions. Now, O king, establish the decree and sign the writing, so that it cannot be changed, according to the law of the Medes and Persians, which does not alter." Therefore King Darius signed the written decree.
The proposal claimed the support of all the governors, though it was aimed at trapping Daniel, who was himself one of the governors. For thirty days, petitions to any god or man except the king would be forbidden, with the lions’ den as the penalty. Once Darius signed it, the conspirators had a law they could use against the man whose work had given them no grounds for a charge.
Daniel knew the decree had been signed. He went home and continued his established practice of praying and giving thanks to God three times a day. The officials found him praying and then presented his faithfulness to God as disregard for the king. Darius tried to find a way to deliver him, but the same men insisted that the law could not be altered. The king who had signed their proposal now found himself bound by it.
Daniel was thrown into the den, and God sent His angel to shut the lions’ mouths. When the king came the next morning, Daniel was alive and uninjured. He explained that he had been found innocent before God and had done no wrong to the king. He had continued to serve God without organizing a violent plot against his accusers. Their scheme had failed because God preserved the man they intended to destroy.
We should also read the next part accurately. Darius ordered the accusers, their wives, and their children to be thrown to the lions. That was a brutal royal action recorded in Daniel 6:24; it is not a command for Christians to punish an offender’s family. The king then proclaimed the greatness of Daniel’s God, whose kingdom would never be destroyed. The account establishes God’s power to deliver, but it does not promise that every believer will see an immediate reversal like Daniel’s.
That difference becomes especially difficult when a wicked plan appears to succeed. Psalm 37 speaks to the person who is watching someone prosper through wrongdoing. It is an acrostic psalm, arranged according to the Hebrew alphabet, and its repeated counsel is to trust the LORD and continue doing good while waiting for His judgment.
Rest in the LORD, and wait patiently for Him; Do not fret because of him who prospers in his way, Because of the man who brings wicked schemes to pass. Cease from anger, and forsake wrath; Do not fret–it only causes harm. For evildoers shall be cut off; But those who wait on the LORD, They shall inherit the earth. For yet a little while and the wicked shall be no more; Indeed, you will look carefully for his place, But it shall be no more. But the meek shall inherit the earth, And shall delight themselves in the abundance of peace.
David does not pretend that wicked people never gain anything. He speaks of a man bringing his schemes to pass, which explains why the person watching could become angry or envious. But David also describes the temporary nature of that power. Later in the psalm he recalls a wicked man who seemed firmly established and then was gone. The LORD knows the days of the upright, and their inheritance will endure.
I understand the promise that the meek will inherit the earth in light of God’s coming kingdom and His final judgment. It is not a promise that every loss will be reversed by next week. A believer may have a long wait, and some wrongs will not be fully answered in this present life. Yet the length of the wait does not mean that God has failed to see. Destroyed messages, concealed conversations, and a powerful person’s influence cannot keep the facts from Him.
Establish Truth, Seek Protection, and Refuse Vengeance
Trusting that God knows the facts should also keep me honest about the facts I do not know. A private meeting, a disagreement, or a mistake is not enough by itself to prove that someone is plotting harm. Fear can make unrelated events look connected. If I am going to accuse someone of a deliberate scheme, I need more than the feeling that there must be one.
In Luke 12:1–12, Jesus warned His disciples about hypocrisy and told them that hidden things would be revealed. He also prepared them for opposition and told them not to fear those who could kill the body. That is assurance that concealment will not defeat God’s judgment. I do not understand it as permission to announce my suspicions publicly as though God had already confirmed them.
Of course, Esther and Daniel also keep us from dismissing every concern about people acting together. Those plots were real. The question is how we establish what has happened in the situation before us. I can begin by separating what someone directly saw or heard from what he thinks it means. Then I can consider whether another witness or a record supports the account, and whether there is a reasonable explanation that has not yet been considered.
Israel’s law took false accusations seriously. Deuteronomy 19:15–21 required more than a single witness to establish a charge, and it instructed the judges to make careful inquiry when a witness was accused of lying. A malicious witness could face the consequence he had intended to bring on another person. The law was concerned with discovering the truth, including the possibility that an accusation itself was being used to do harm.
Jesus drew on the principle of witnesses when He taught His disciples about addressing sin in Matthew 18:15–20. Paul likewise told Timothy to handle accusations against elders with witnesses and without partiality in 1 Timothy 5:19–21. Neither popularity nor dislike should decide the outcome. The person making a report and the person accused both need the matter examined honestly.
I would not use those passages to refuse to hear a person until he can bring a second eyewitness, or to require someone in danger to confront an alleged abuser alone. Hearing a report is how an inquiry can begin. Evidence may include messages, financial records, physical evidence, or independent testimony that confirms part of the account. A person describing harm should be helped to report it safely, while those responsible examine what can actually be established.
If you are keeping a record, preserve the original messages and documents rather than changing them to strengthen your case. Write down what happened and when, being clear about what you remember and what you are uncertain about. A timeline can help someone understand the sequence, but it should not make an uncertain memory look exact. The purpose is to allow the facts to be examined, including facts that might challenge your first understanding.
Reporting a concern to someone responsible for addressing it is not the same as spreading gossip. Civil authorities may need to investigate a crime, church leaders may need to protect people in the congregation, and an employer or licensing body may have responsibilities within its own area. A family member may need information to keep someone safe. Share what is relevant with those who need to act, and distinguish a concern from a finding. Publicly repeating an unproved charge can injure people without helping anyone reach the truth.
There are also situations where protection cannot wait for a completed inquiry. Separating people or limiting access while a credible concern is examined does not have to be presented as a final verdict. It can be a necessary precaution while the facts are being established. I think we need to leave room for that, because demanding certainty before taking any protective action can leave a vulnerable person exposed to further harm.
If there is an immediate threat, get to safety and contact emergency services. Suspected criminal conduct should be brought to the appropriate civil authorities, and a qualified legal adviser can help with questions about your situation. Churches and workplaces should also take reasonable steps within their responsibilities to prevent further access to those at risk. Prayer belongs in that response, and seeking practical help does too.
We can see that in what happened to Paul in Acts 23:12–35. Paul was a prisoner in Roman custody when more than forty men vowed not to eat or drink until they had killed him. They wanted the Jewish council to ask the commander to bring Paul before them under the pretense of further inquiry, so that they could attack him on the way. Paul’s nephew heard about the ambush and told him. Paul then arranged for the young man to speak to the Roman commander, who sent Paul away under guard. Paul did not treat using that protection as a failure to trust God.
David’s conduct toward Saul shows another part of the same concern. This happened before David became king, while Saul was still ruling Israel and was pursuing David to kill him. In 1 Samuel 24, Saul entered a cave where David and his men were hiding. David had an opportunity to attack him, but he restrained his men and refused to kill the king. After Saul left the cave, David called out and explained what had happened, asking the LORD to judge between them. Yet when their conversation ended, David and his men went to the stronghold. Refusing to take vengeance did not mean placing himself back under Saul’s power.
That brings us to Paul’s instructions in Romans 12. Earlier in the chapter, he tells believers to love sincerely and to abhor evil. His command against revenge therefore cannot mean becoming indifferent to the wrong. He is explaining how to respond without allowing another person’s evil to determine our own conduct.
Repay no one evil for evil. Have regard for good things in the sight of all men. If it is possible, as much as depends on you, live peaceably with all men. Beloved, do not avenge yourselves, but rather give place to wrath; for it is written, "Vengeance is Mine, I will repay," says the Lord. Therefore "If your enemy is hungry, feed him; If he is thirsty, give him a drink; For in so doing you will heap coals of fire on his head." Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.
Pay attention to the qualification about peace: as much as depends on you. Another person may refuse peace even when you are willing to live rightly toward him. Paul does not make you responsible for controlling his choice. He does forbid repaying evil with evil, and he tells you to leave vengeance with God. Feeding a hungry enemy expresses mercy toward him; it does not require giving him the means to continue harming someone.
The next chapter explains that governing authority has a responsibility to restrain and punish wrongdoing. Reading Romans 12 and 13 together, I understand a distinction between personal vengeance and the proper pursuit of justice. Reporting a crime or seeking lawful protection does not require hatred. I can want the harm stopped and the truth established while also wanting the offender to repent.
Forgiveness does not require destroying evidence, hiding a danger from people who need to know, or preventing lawful consequences. Nor does it mean that trust and access must immediately be restored. Reconciliation requires truth, and trust needs grounds in conduct that has become trustworthy. A person can surrender the desire to make an offender suffer and still protect a home, finances, or vulnerable family members.
I have to watch my own conduct through that process. If I fabricate evidence, threaten someone’s family, spread rumors, or manipulate people toward a verdict I have already decided on, I am using the very kinds of methods this study condemns. A wrong done to me does not authorize a scheme of my own. I can seek help and press for a truthful account without making myself the judge and executioner.
The Plot Against Jesus and God’s Saving Purpose
Haman was exposed, and Daniel was preserved alive in the lions’ den. When we come to the plot against Jesus, we find that those seeking His death were allowed to carry it out. I think we need to see that clearly before we speak about God’s purpose, because the resurrection does not make the betrayal, false testimony, and crucifixion something harmless.
In Matthew 26:1–2, Jesus told His disciples that He would be delivered up to be crucified at the time of Passover. Matthew then describes the gathering at the palace of Caiaphas, the high priest. These leaders were considering how to seize and kill the very One who had already told His disciples what was coming.
Then the chief priests, the scribes, and the elders of the people assembled at the palace of the high priest, who was called Caiaphas, and plotted to take Jesus by trickery and kill Him. But they said, "Not during the feast, lest there be an uproar among the people."
Their concern about the feast was that an arrest might provoke an uproar among the people. Soon afterward, Judas, one of Jesus’ twelve disciples, went to the chief priests and asked what they would give him to hand Jesus over. They counted out thirty pieces of silver, and he began looking for an opportunity to betray Him. That made someone close to Jesus part of the plan. I discuss his actions further in the study on Judas Iscariot, but Matthew’s sequence already makes his involvement clear.
After the arrest, the council sought false testimony to obtain a death sentence. Jesus was then taken to Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor, where the chief priests and elders persuaded the crowd to demand His crucifixion. Pilate had Him scourged and handed Him over, and the soldiers mocked and struck Him before crucifying Him. Religious office and civil authority were both involved, but neither made the injustice righteous. The people taking part were responsible for what they did.
Then, after Jesus had risen from the dead and returned to Heaven, the Holy Spirit came upon His followers at Pentecost. The crowd heard them speaking about God’s works in languages the hearers understood. Peter, one of Jesus’ apostles, explained the outpouring by referring to the prophet Joel, and then he spoke directly about Jesus. In Acts 2:22–24, he placed God’s saving purpose and the responsibility of those who crucified Jesus in the same explanation.
"Men of Israel, hear these words: Jesus of Nazareth, a Man attested by God to you by miracles, wonders, and signs which God did through Him in your midst, as you yourselves also know– Him, being delivered by the determined purpose and foreknowledge of God, you have taken by lawless hands, have crucified, and put to death; whom God raised up, having loosed the pains of death, because it was not possible that He should be held by it."
Peter did not say that their actions were righteous because God had foreknown what would happen. He called their hands lawless. At the same time, he did not present God as having lost control and then found a way to recover. Jesus’ death belonged to God’s determined purpose, and God raised Him because death could not hold Him. I understand those statements to mean that God accomplished His saving purpose without forcing the men involved to lie, betray, or murder.
Peter went on to explain the resurrection from Psalm 16. David had written about God’s Holy One not being abandoned to the realm of the dead or undergoing bodily decay. Peter pointed out that David himself had died and been buried, and that his tomb was still known to them. As a prophet, David had been speaking ahead of time about the Messiah. Peter identified Jesus as that risen Messiah and testified that the apostles had seen Him alive. The term Hades in the passage refers to the realm of the dead; Peter’s point is that Jesus was not left there and His body did not decay.
That also helps us keep God’s purpose distinct from the purpose of the conspirators. They intended to get rid of Jesus. He willingly gave His life to save sinners. In John 10:17–18, Jesus explained that He had authority to lay down His life and to take it again, in obedience to His Father’s command. His willingness did not make the attackers innocent, but their violence did not turn Him into an unwilling Savior.
I do not understand the cross as the Father punishing, cursing, or abandoning His Son. Nor do I understand it as the Father striking or bruising Jesus and pouring wrath on Him. Jesus’ atonement, the sacrifice through which our sins are dealt with and forgiveness is provided, rests on His perfection and His being slain as the perfect sacrifice. Hebrews 9:14 describes Him offering Himself without spot to God through the eternal Spirit. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit were united in the work of redemption. Before His arrest, Jesus had also told His disciples that although they would leave Him, He was not alone because the Father was with Him (John 16:32).
The identity of the One giving His life is essential to that understanding. John 1 tells us that the Word was with God and was God, and that the Word became flesh. The eternal Son became truly man without ceasing to be God. Luke 1:26–35 records the announcement that the virgin Mary would bear Him through the work of the Holy Spirit, and Hebrews 4:15 identifies Him as without sin. He was not another guilty person attempting to repair His own wrongdoing.
He shed His blood for us and completed His sacrificial work on the cross before His burial. John 19:28–42 places His declaration that the work was finished before His death and the laying of His body in the tomb. His bodily resurrection then defeated death and confirmed the hope Peter proclaimed. God did not declare the evil actions good; He brought salvation through the willing offering of His perfect Son and raised Him from the dead.
That salvation is offered to the very kind of guilty people we have been discussing. Christ’s sacrifice was for the whole world, as 1 John 2:2 explains, and 1 Timothy 2:1–6 speaks of God’s desire for all to be saved and of Christ giving Himself as a ransom for all. I understand that offer to be sincere. God’s grace enables a real response, and it can be resisted. A person must repent and believe in Christ rather than continue refusing Him.
The sinner who comes to Christ is justified, forgiven, and given new life by grace through faith. Those words describe what God does for the believer: He counts the person righteous in Christ, forgives his sin, and brings him into new life as His child. Ephesians 2:8–10 makes clear that salvation is His gift rather than payment for our works, and that good works follow as the life He intends us to live. Ephesians 1:13–14 says that those who believe are sealed with the Holy Spirit, who guarantees their inheritance. I believe the truly born-again believer is permanently secure in Christ. That assurance is not a license to continue scheming, and an empty profession of faith is not the same as having received Him.
Repentance Requires Truth and Concrete Repair
Because forgiveness comes through Christ, a person who has devised harm does not have to keep defending it to avoid facing what he has done. He can confess the sin and turn from it. But confessing it means admitting the actual wrong. Calling a deliberate lie a misunderstanding while leaving others to suffer from it is still a way of concealing the truth.
Paul describes the change in Ephesians 4. Before giving the particular instructions below, he tells believers to put off their former conduct, to be renewed in their minds, and to put on the new man created according to God. Then he explains what that means in the ordinary ways they speak and deal with one another.
Therefore, putting away lying, "Let each one of you speak truth with his neighbor," for we are members of one another. "Be angry, and do not sin": do not let the sun go down on your wrath, nor give place to the devil. Let him who stole steal no longer, but rather let him labor, working with his hands what is good, that he may have something to give him who has need. Let no corrupt word proceed out of your mouth, but what is good for necessary edification, that it may impart grace to the hearers.
The person who lied is to speak truth. The person who stole is to work honestly, and he is to become someone who can give to a person in need. Words that once corrupted a conversation are to be replaced by words that help the hearer. Paul explains why truthfulness belongs in the church by reminding believers that they are members of one another. I cannot treat another believer as someone to injure for my advantage while taking that relationship seriously.
For someone involved in a scheme, the first practical step is to stop carrying it out. That includes stopping the pressure on anyone who has been recruited to cooperate. If I have persuaded others to believe a false accusation, I need to correct it with the people who heard it. A quiet apology to the person I injured may leave the same damaging claim circulating everywhere else.
If money or property was taken, repentance should lead toward returning it and addressing the loss as far as that is possible. If others helped conceal what happened, I must stop protecting the arrangement and tell the truth about my involvement. These actions can be costly, and some consequences cannot be undone. That does not give me a reason to leave the harm in place when there is something I can do to repair it.
I do not mean that restitution purchases God’s forgiveness or that a believer maintains salvation by completing a sufficient amount of repair. Christ’s work is the basis of forgiveness. The change in conduct is the fruit of turning from the sin. Someone who claims to have repented while deliberately preserving the benefit of his wrongdoing gives those he injured reason to question whether he has actually turned from it.
God’s forgiveness also does not cancel every earthly consequence. A person may still face lawful proceedings, lose a position of trust, or have to accept limits that protect those he hurt. Trust can take time to rebuild because other people need to see that the conduct has changed. I discuss that relationship between confession and changed conduct further in the study on repentance. The injured person should not be pressured to act as though the damage disappeared the moment an apology was offered.
Paul closes Ephesians 4 by telling believers to put away bitterness, malice, and evil speaking, and to forgive as God in Christ forgave them. That speaks to the injured person too. God does not ask him to call the injury good, but He does call him away from cultivating his own plan to do harm in return. The offender’s need to repent and the injured person’s need to surrender vengeance can both be taken seriously.
As I apply this to my own planning, I need to look beyond whether I can defend my goal. Am I withholding something because I need the other person to misunderstand? Have I dressed up a desire for control in spiritual language? Am I only seeking advice from people who will agree with me? Those questions bring the teaching into the decisions I am actually making, where a wrong method can begin to seem acceptable because I am so determined to get a particular result.
The same examination belongs in ministry. A teacher’s claim to serve God does not justify manipulating the people listening to him. That is one reason the warnings about false teachers require us to examine teaching and conduct by Scripture. A reputation or a religious explanation must not become a reason to ignore deception. At the same time, accusing a teacher requires the same care with truth that I would want applied to an accusation against me.
If you believe you are being targeted, begin with what can be established and seek help from people able to respond responsibly. Preserve relevant evidence, report credible threats, and take appropriate steps to protect those in danger. You do not have to persuade an online crowd before you are allowed to ask for help. If instead you recognize that you have been arranging the harm, stop the plan, tell the truth to the people affected, and turn to Christ. His mercy gives you reason to come out of concealment.
My Final Thoughts
The passages we have considered bring a plan under God’s judgment before it succeeds. The desire in the heart, the lie that recruits another person, and the use of power against someone who cannot easily resist are already known to Him. Haman’s position and the signed decree against Daniel did not make their plots righteous. I cannot make a plan right by giving it an impressive explanation either.
I also have to carry that concern for truth into the way I respond to wrongdoing. I can seek protection, preserve evidence, and ask for justice without inventing motives or arranging retaliation. God has not asked me to ignore evil, but He has kept final judgment in His own hands. Because He knows what happened, I do not have to add anything false to make the case stronger.
The plot against Jesus did not defeat God’s saving purpose, and Christ’s willing sacrifice has opened the way for guilty people to be forgiven. His mercy gives me reason to acknowledge whatever is wrong in my own plans and to change what I am doing. I want the good I hope to accomplish to be pursued in a way that is truthful toward the people affected by it, with the outcome entrusted to the God who sees us all.