The Parable of the Lost Sheep: What It Means in Luke and Matthew

Jesus told the parable of the lost sheep while people were complaining about the sinners He welcomed. The shepherd in His illustration was glad to recover what had been lost, and he wanted others to share his joy. I find that contrast helpful because it makes the parable personal: I can admire the shepherd’s concern and still resent seeing someone I dislike receive mercy.

Matthew records the wandering sheep in another setting, where Jesus was teaching His disciples how to regard people they might consider unimportant. If we read both passages in their settings, we can see how His care confronts both the refusal to welcome a repentant sinner and the neglect of someone who has wandered.

Why Jesus Told the Parable in Luke 15

Luke 15 begins with tax collectors and people known as sinners drawing near to hear Jesus. Tax collectors gathered revenue within the Roman world, and their work could become a means of taking more from people than they owed. That abuse helps explain the contempt with which they were often regarded. In Luke 3:12–13, John the Baptist, who was calling people to repentance, specifically told tax collectors who came to him not to collect more than the amount appointed.

The people objecting to Jesus’ welcome were Pharisees and scribes. The Pharisees were a Jewish religious movement concerned with strict observance of God’s law, and the scribes studied and taught that law. These men complained because Jesus received sinners and ate with them. Eating together expressed a personal welcome, and they objected to His giving that welcome to people whose conduct they condemned.

Luke also tells us what those people were coming to do: they wanted to hear Jesus. He did not have to declare their sins harmless in order to receive them and teach them. His explanation of the parable would connect heaven’s joy to repentance. We should keep that explanation in view as we hear His answer to the complaint.

What man of you, having a hundred sheep, if he loses one of them, does not leave the ninety-nine in the wilderness, and go after the one which is lost until he finds it? And when he has found it, he lays it on his shoulders, rejoicing. And when he comes home, he calls together his friends and neighbors, saying to them, ‘Rejoice with me, for I have found my sheep which was lost!’ I say to you that likewise there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents than over ninety-nine just persons who need no repentance.

Luke 15:4-7

The man had a hundred sheep, but one of them was missing. Jesus describes him leaving the ninety-nine and going after the one until he found it. He did not decide that having most of the flock was good enough or that the missing sheep had become worthless because it was lost. He acted to recover what belonged to him.

The Greek word used for lost is a form of apollymi. Depending on its context, that word can refer to losing something, ruining it, or destroying it. Here the sheep is alive but separated from the flock. It needs to be found and brought back. I would not make the word mean physical death in every passage when Jesus is plainly describing the recovery of a living animal.

Luke says the ninety-nine were left in the wilderness, or open country. He does not tell us that the shepherd placed them in a secure pen or assigned another shepherd to guard them. Those arrangements are possible, but they are not details Jesus gives us. Nor do I think we should turn the illustration into an instruction for church leaders to leave everyone else without care whenever one person wanders. The search shows the concern given to the one who is missing.

When the shepherd finds the sheep, he puts it on his shoulders and rejoices. He does the work of carrying it back, and he is glad to do it. Then, when he reaches home, he calls his friends and neighbors together so that they can rejoice with him. The recovery is something he wants to share rather than keep to himself.

Jesus explains that joy in terms of heaven rejoicing over one sinner who repents. That explanation answers the people who had been complaining. They were offended by His welcome, while heaven rejoiced when a sinner turned to God. The shepherd’s invitation to his neighbors leaves me asking whether I am willing to join in that joy when the person receiving mercy is someone whose past troubles me.

Jesus continues with a woman who has ten silver coins and loses one. She lights a lamp, sweeps the house, and searches carefully until she finds it. When she does, she also calls her friends and neighbors to rejoice with her. Jesus again explains the celebration as joy in the presence of God’s angels over one sinner who repents. The repeated celebration keeps the original complaint before His hearers.

The final parable in Luke 15 describes a father and his two sons. The younger son takes his share of the family property, goes away, and wastes it. After losing what he had and suffering hunger, he returns to his father and confesses his sin. His father receives him and calls for a celebration. But when the older son learns why the household is celebrating, he becomes angry and refuses to go in.

The father then comes out and pleads with the older son, explaining why his brother’s return is a reason to be glad. That response exposes another way of being wrong: a person can remain close to the household and still resent the father’s mercy. I hear the complaint of the Pharisees and scribes reflected in that refusal to celebrate. The study on the Prodigal Son follows the final parable in more detail, but the connection here is the joy that recovery brings and the resistance of those who will not share it.

Jesus’ reference to ninety-nine just persons who need no repentance also needs to be read carefully. He cannot mean that there are people who have never sinned and never needed God’s forgiveness. Some understand Him to be referring to people already walking faithfully, who do not need the particular return represented by the missing sheep. On that understanding, the special joy of recovering one does not mean the other ninety-nine have become less valuable.

In Luke’s setting, I also hear irony directed toward people who regarded themselves as righteous while resenting His mercy to others. A similar exchange appears earlier in Luke’s Gospel, in Luke 5:27–32. Jesus called a tax collector named Levi to follow Him, and Levi then gave a feast at his house. When the Pharisees and scribes complained about the company Jesus kept there, He compared His work to a physician caring for the sick. He had come to call sinners to repentance.

That comparison did not make a self-satisfied religious person sinless. Someone who believes he needs no mercy can be blind to his own condition. In Luke 15, contempt for those coming to hear Jesus gave the leaders something to repent of themselves. Respectability did not put them beyond the need they recognized so readily in other people.

There is also a limit to how far we should press the behavior of the sheep. The animal does not make a confession, and the shepherd carries it home rather than requiring it to walk back on its own. Yet Jesus explicitly says that this recovery represents a sinner who repents. His explanation should govern what we take from the picture. An animal’s behavior cannot answer every question about a human response to God.

Repentance means turning from rebellion to God, agreeing with Him about sin and trusting Jesus Christ. Regretting the consequences or being embarrassed that other people found out is not the same as turning to Him. Tears may accompany that response, but tears do not prove it. Neither does an attempt to make ourselves respectable purchase forgiveness. The study on repentance develops that distinction more fully.

God is the One who graciously seeks the lost, and the sinner really does respond in repentance. That is why I would not use the carried sheep to argue that God’s grace cannot be resisted. Calvinists who teach irresistible grace generally mean that God renews a person’s will so that he comes willingly, as Westminster Confession 10 explains. I reject its restriction of that effective saving call to a selected group. God’s offer of salvation is genuine for every person, and His grace can be resisted.

We can see that resistance in Jesus’ words in John 5:39–40. He told people who searched the Scriptures that those Scriptures testified of Him, yet they were unwilling to come to Him for life. The shepherd carrying his sheep in Luke 15 does not cancel what Jesus says about people refusing Him. The sinner who repents receives mercy freely, without having earned the Shepherd’s willingness to seek him.

That leaves me with a practical question about my own response. If someone with a publicly shameful past turns to Christ, am I glad that he has received mercy, or do I want him kept at a distance because of what he used to be? Serious wrongdoing can leave harm that requires safeguards, and trust may need time to be rebuilt. Rejoicing in repentance does not mean immediately placing someone in leadership. But discernment should not become a respectable name for refusing to welcome someone God has forgiven.

The Warning in Matthew 18

Matthew’s setting begins with the disciples asking Jesus who is greatest in the kingdom of heaven. Jesus called a little child to Him and placed that child among them. Before discussing their rank, He told them that they needed to turn and become like little children in order to enter the kingdom at all. The one who humbled himself like that child was greatest, and receiving such a child in His name meant receiving Him.

The disciples’ question concerned greatness, but Jesus directed their attention to someone who could offer them no impressive status in return. He then spoke about little ones who believed in Him and warned against causing them to sin. The child before them helped make the warning concrete. A desire for importance must not make a person careless with those who are vulnerable.

Take heed that you do not despise one of these little ones, for I say to you that in heaven their angels always see the face of My Father who is in heaven. For the Son of Man has come to save that which was lost. “What do you think? If a man has a hundred sheep, and one of them goes astray, does he not leave the ninety-nine and go to the mountains to seek the one that is straying? And if he should find it, assuredly, I say to you, he rejoices more over that sheep than over the ninety-nine that did not go astray. Even so it is not the will of your Father who is in heaven that one of these little ones should perish.

Matthew 18:10-14

The warning about despising these little ones follows severe words about harming them. In Matthew 18:6–9, Jesus says that it would be better for someone who caused a little one to stumble to have a millstone hung around his neck and be drowned in the sea. A millstone is a heavy stone used for grinding grain. The severity of the comparison tells us how seriously He regards the harm done to those who believe in Him.

He also tells His hearers to remove a hand, foot, or eye if it causes them to sin. I understand that language as a call to break decisively with what draws us into evil, not as a claim that injuring the body can cure a sinful heart. If I keep protecting an influence that leads me into wrongdoing, I have not taken His warning seriously. My refusal to deal with it can also expose other people to harm.

Jesus identifies the little ones as people who believe in Him, so His concern reaches vulnerable believers as well as the child He placed before the disciples. They must not be treated as expendable because they have little influence or standing. The disciples could not claim to honor Christ while despising those whose welfare mattered to Him.

He explains that their angels always see His Father’s face in heaven. Some understand that wording to describe an individual guardian angel assigned to each person; others understand it collectively of angels serving these believers before God. Jesus does not explain the assignments in enough detail for me to settle that question. What He does establish is that heaven is not indifferent to the people others might overlook.

I think that should affect the way a church notices people. It can be easy to give attention to someone whose money, ability, or public reputation seems useful, while becoming impatient with someone who needs repeated instruction or practical help. A young believer, a poor family, or a person living with a disability must not become beneath our concern. Jesus’ command reaches the value we place on them, not merely whether we use polite words.

After warning against that contempt, Jesus describes a shepherd seeking a sheep that has gone astray. He leaves the ninety-nine and goes into the mountains to look for the one that has wandered. The Greek wording associated with planomai describes going astray or being led astray. The sheep has moved away, and the shepherd’s response is to seek it.

There is a difference in the wording of the two passages that I want to keep. Luke describes the search continuing until the shepherd finds the sheep. Matthew speaks of what happens if he finds it. Luke gives us a successful recovery and explains it as a sinner’s repentance. Matthew calls the disciples to care for the wanderer without telling them that they can control another person’s response.

The joy when the sheep is found shows how much that one matters to the shepherd. Jesus concludes by saying that it is not the Father’s will for one of these little ones to perish. The disciples therefore cannot justify neglecting one person by pointing out that most of their group seems to be doing well. The Father’s concern reaches the one whose absence might be inconvenient to address.

I do not understand the Father’s desire as a promise that every person will finally be saved regardless of his response. Jesus elsewhere speaks about people refusing to come to Him, and John 3:16–18 distinguishes believing from remaining in condemnation through unbelief. His gracious invitation is real, and rejection is real too. We should seek a wanderer’s good rather than use God’s concern as an excuse to assume that nothing is at stake.

At the same time, I would not use Matthew’s warning to overturn Christ’s promise to keep those who are genuinely born again. A believer who wanders can injure himself and others, suffer God’s discipline, and need serious correction while his eternal life remains secure. Security in Christ gives us no reason to leave him on a harmful path. The Father cares about what happens to His children, and our care should reflect that concern.

That care may involve prayer, a truthful conversation, patient correction, or practical help with an obstacle the person is facing. It cannot mean defending an abusive leader while neglecting the person he has harmed. Nor should we pressure someone into an unsafe meeting and then call that pressure an act of restoration. Jesus has just warned His disciples about harming the little ones; we cannot obey the parable by disregarding that warning.

Matthew 18:11 states the Son of Man’s purpose in coming to save the lost. I retain that verse with the received Greek text followed by the NKJV. Some translations omit it from their main text because of manuscript differences, and the NET textual note explains its editors’ decision. That note describes a different textual judgment from the one I follow. Luke 19:10 also states Christ’s purpose to seek and save the lost, and Matthew’s surrounding teaching expresses the Father’s care for those the disciples must not despise.

Reading Luke and Matthew together does not require us to erase those different settings. Luke answers resentment toward sinners who repent. Matthew teaches disciples to humble themselves and seek the good of vulnerable people, including those who stray. Jesus may have used the illustration on more than one occasion, or the Gospels may preserve forms of His teaching suited to the settings they record. I receive both as inspired Scripture and want each passage to retain the explanation it gives us.

The Shepherd God Promised

The picture of God caring for His people as a shepherd did not begin with these parables. Through the prophet Ezekiel, God had already confronted Israel’s leaders for failing to care for the people entrusted to them. Ezekiel 34 calls those leaders shepherds, but describes them feeding themselves at the expense of the flock.

They took the fat and wool for themselves while failing to strengthen the weak, care for the sick, or bind up the broken. They did not bring back those who had been driven away or search for those who were lost. Their harsh treatment left the flock scattered and exposed to harm. God announced that He would hold those shepherds responsible and deliver His people from them.

He then promised to do the work they had neglected. He would search for His sheep, gather them out of the countries where they had been scattered, and bring them into their own land. His words about pasture and rest follow that promise of rescue.

“I will feed them in good pasture, and their fold shall be on the high mountains of Israel. There they shall lie down in a good fold and feed in rich pasture on the mountains of Israel. I will feed My flock, and I will make them lie down,” says the Lord GOD. “I will seek what was lost and bring back what was driven away, bind up the broken and strengthen what was sick; but I will destroy the fat and the strong, and feed them in judgment.”

Ezekiel 34:14-16

God names the needs the leaders had ignored: the lost need to be sought, those driven away need to be brought back, and the broken and sick need care. He also says that He will judge the fat and strong. The rest of the chapter explains how powerful members of the flock had pushed the weak aside and spoiled the pasture and water others needed. God’s shepherding includes protecting His people from those who harm them.

That means an abusive leader cannot claim the comfort of this passage while refusing its correction. The LORD is against shepherds who use the flock for themselves. His promise to rescue the sheep is also a warning to anyone who thinks authority entitles him to mistreat those under his care.

Later in Ezekiel 34, God promises one shepherd over His people, identified as His servant David. David had been Israel’s king, and God had promised that his royal house and throne would endure. I understand Ezekiel’s promise to refer to the Davidic Messiah, the King who would come from David’s line. When Jesus calls Himself the Good Shepherd and seeks the lost, He is doing the work God said He would do for His people.

That connection helps me understand who Jesus is, as well as what He does. Yet applying His care to Christians does not remove the promises Ezekiel makes about Israel. God names their own land and the mountains of Israel. I do not take the church’s relationship with the Shepherd as permission to cancel the nation’s future in that passage.

David’s words in Psalm 23 describe that care personally. He speaks of the LORD as his own Shepherd, and he explains what he can depend on as he follows Him.

The LORD is my shepherd; I shall not want. He makes me to lie down in green pastures; He leads me beside the still waters. He restores my soul; He leads me in the paths of righteousness For His name’s sake. Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil; For You are with me; Your rod and Your staff, they comfort me. You prepare a table before me in the presence of my enemies; You anoint my head with oil; My cup runs over. Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me All the days of my life; And I will dwell in the house of the LORD Forever.

Psalm 23:1-6

The Shepherd supplies pasture and water, restores David’s soul, and leads him in paths of righteousness. His provision includes guidance about where to walk. That helps me understand why caring for someone can require warning him about a path that will hurt him. Reassurance that leaves him walking toward danger would fail to give the kind of care David describes.

David also speaks about walking through the valley of the shadow of death. The Shepherd’s presence does not mean there will be no frightening place to pass through. It means David is not abandoned there. The rod and staff belong to the Shepherd’s care, and their presence gives him comfort amid the danger.

The psalm then pictures the LORD’s generosity through a table prepared in the presence of enemies, oil upon David’s head, and a cup that overflows. His enemies have not ceased to exist, but neither have they prevented God from caring for him. David looks ahead with confidence in goodness and mercy and in dwelling in the LORD’s house. Being brought back to the Shepherd is the beginning of a life under His care, not the end of our need for Him.

Isaiah 40 also describes the LORD as a shepherd, but it first announces comfort for His people and calls Jerusalem to proclaim His coming. The passage places His power to rule beside His care for the weak.

O Zion, You who bring good tidings, Get up into the high mountain; O Jerusalem, You who bring good tidings, Lift up your voice with strength, Lift it up, be not afraid; Say to the cities of Judah, “Behold your God!” Behold, the Lord GOD shall come with a strong hand, And His arm shall rule for Him; Behold, His reward is with Him, And His work before Him. He will feed His flock like a shepherd; He will gather the lambs with His arm, And carry them in His bosom, And gently lead those who are with young.

Isaiah 40:9-11

The same arm that rules gathers the lambs and carries them close. The Lord gently leads those with young because He cares for the flock according to its needs. I do not see a leader’s harshness justified by this picture of authority. God’s strength enables Him to protect the dependent rather than treat their weakness as an irritation.

Later in Isaiah, the sheep image is used to describe why people need rescue at all. Isaiah 53 speaks about the LORD’s innocent Servant suffering for others, and it compares those who need His saving work to sheep that have wandered away.

Surely He has borne our griefs And carried our sorrows; Yet we esteemed Him stricken, Smitten by God, and afflicted. But He was wounded for our transgressions, He was bruised for our iniquities; The chastisement for our peace was upon Him, And by His stripes we are healed. All we like sheep have gone astray; We have turned, every one, to his own way; And the LORD has laid on Him the iniquity of us all.

Isaiah 53:4-6

Isaiah includes all of us in that wandering. Each has turned to his own way. The outward consequences of rebellion differ, and one person’s sin may attract more public attention than another’s, but choosing my way against God’s is not made righteous by a good reputation. The religious observer who criticizes a notorious sinner still needs the mercy described here.

I understand this Servant to be Jesus Christ. He bears our griefs, sorrows, and iniquity while suffering innocently for us. Isaiah also records how people regarded Him as stricken and smitten by God. I distinguish that judgment about Him from the saving work He was actually accomplishing through His willing sacrifice.

His bearing our sins means that He voluntarily gave Himself to be slain as the sinless sacrifice for us. Wicked people inflicted His wounds and death. God’s appointment of Him as our sin-bearer does not mean that the Father tortured or punished His Son. The Shepherd’s rescue comes through His own perfect, willing offering.

The people described as having all gone astray are the people whose iniquity He bears. I understand His saving provision to be for the whole world, genuinely offered to every person. No religious observer can reasonably object that someone else’s need is too great for that mercy while forgetting how much he needs it himself.

Jesus Seeks, Saves, and Keeps His Sheep

Luke 19 records an encounter that puts Jesus’ care for the lost into the life of a particular person. Zacchaeus was a wealthy chief tax collector in Jericho, and he wanted to see who Jesus was as He passed through the city. Because he was short and could not see over the crowd, he ran ahead and climbed a sycamore tree.

When Jesus reached that place, He looked up, called Zacchaeus by name, and told him to come down because He must stay at his house that day. Zacchaeus came down quickly and received Him with joy. The crowd’s response was very different. As in Luke 15, people complained about the kind of man Jesus was willing to receive.

But when they saw it, they all complained, saying, “He has gone to be a guest with a man who is a sinner.” Then Zacchaeus stood and said to the Lord, “Look, Lord, I give half of my goods to the poor; and if I have taken anything from anyone by false accusation, I restore fourfold.” And Jesus said to him, “Today salvation has come to this house, because he also is a son of Abraham; for the Son of Man has come to seek and to save that which was lost.”

Luke 19:7-10

Zacchaeus answered with a commitment that addressed the way he used his possessions and the possibility of his having cheated people. He would give half his goods to the poor, and if he had taken anything by false accusation, he would restore it fourfold. Restitution means returning what was wrongfully taken, and his commitment went beyond simply giving back the original amount.

He was not offering a vague expression of regret while refusing to face the harm his conduct could have caused. His response gave evidence of repentance through generosity and a willingness to make restitution. But those actions could not buy salvation. Jesus announced that salvation had come to the house and then explained His own purpose in coming to seek and save the lost.

Jesus also identified Zacchaeus as a son of Abraham. Abraham was the forefather of Israel, the people to whom God had given His covenant promises. Being descended from Abraham had not removed his need for a Savior or made any dishonest conduct harmless. Now he was receiving the One who had come for people who were lost. The crowd’s disapproval did not keep Jesus from showing mercy, and the people watching had reason to rejoice instead of continuing to complain.

John 10 explains more fully who this Shepherd is. The preceding chapter records Jesus giving sight to a man born blind. Religious leaders questioned the man, rejected his testimony about Jesus, and cast him out. Jesus then found him, made Himself known to him as the Son of God, and received his faith and worship. That encounter gives us a setting in which to hear the contrast between those who harm the flock and the Shepherd who cares for it.

Jesus begins with a sheepfold, an enclosure for sheep, and the difference between entering through its door and climbing in another way. The shepherd calls his own sheep by name and leads them, while a thief enters to take what is not his. Jesus then identifies Himself as the door through which a person receives salvation and finds life. His words about thieves and robbers concern false claimants who exploit the flock; I do not understand Him to be condemning the faithful prophets God sent before Him.

He also contrasts His care with that of a hireling, a man hired to watch sheep he does not own. When the wolf comes, the hireling runs because he does not care for them, and the flock is left exposed. Jesus says that the Good Shepherd gives His life for the sheep. He then explains both His relationship with them and His authority over His own life.

I am the good shepherd; and I know My sheep, and am known by My own. As the Father knows Me, even so I know the Father; and I lay down My life for the sheep. And other sheep I have which are not of this fold; them also I must bring, and they will hear My voice; and there will be one flock and one shepherd. “Therefore My Father loves Me, because I lay down My life that I may take it again. No one takes it from Me, but I lay it down of Myself. I have power to lay it down, and I have power to take it again. This command I have received from My Father.”

John 10:14-18

Jesus knows His sheep, and they know Him. He describes that relationship while also speaking of His knowledge of the Father and the Father’s knowledge of Him. His care is personal, and His willingness to give His life shows that it continues when caring for the sheep is costly.

He also says that He has authority to lay down His life and to take it again. I understand those words in terms of His actual death and bodily resurrection. Jesus was not merely promising that His example would influence people after He was gone. He would die, and He would rise to continue caring for those who belong to Him.

Wicked men were responsible for torturing and killing Him, but their violence did not make Him an unwilling victim or defeat God’s foreknown purpose. He freely gave Himself for us. The Father’s command and the Son’s willing obedience belong together here. His life was offered in the work of saving His people.

The risen Shepherd continues to lead, and His written word governs how we recognize His voice. A person may believe that the Lord is impressing something upon him, but that impression has no authority to contradict Scripture. Following Jesus cannot mean setting aside what He has already made known in order to follow a private feeling.

Jesus also speaks of other sheep who are not of the present fold, whom He will bring into one flock under one Shepherd. I understand this to include Gentiles, people of the other nations, brought into saving fellowship with believing Jews through the gospel. Ephesians 2:11–22 explains that people once far off have been brought near through Christ’s blood and that both have access to the Father through Him.

Their unity does not turn Gentiles into ethnic Israelites or transfer Israel’s land promises to the church. They share salvation under one Shepherd while God’s promises retain what He said about their recipients. The study on Jesus as the Good Shepherd develops His identity and care more fully.

His statement that He gives His life for the sheep also does not say that He dies only for that group. In 1 John 2:2, His provision for sin is described in relation to the whole world. I cannot use John 10 to limit the sacrifice to a predetermined group when Scripture identifies its provision more broadly. The offer of salvation is genuine for all, and those who receive Him have life in Him.

Later in John 10, the setting is the Feast of Dedication in Jerusalem. Jesus was walking in the temple when opponents surrounded Him and demanded that He tell them plainly whether He was the Christ, the promised Messiah. He answered that He had already told them, and that the works He did in His Father’s name testified about Him. They were refusing the testimony already before them.

“But you do not believe, because you are not of My sheep, as I said to you. My sheep hear My voice, and I know them, and they follow Me. And I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; neither shall anyone snatch them out of My hand. My Father, who has given them to Me, is greater than all; and no one is able to snatch them out of My Father’s hand. I and My Father are one.”

John 10:26-30

Jesus distinguishes His unbelieving opponents from the sheep who hear His voice, are known by Him, and follow Him. Their religious standing could not give them a relationship with the Shepherd they refused to believe. Asking for another statement did not remove their responsibility for how they had responded to what He had said and done.

What He promises His sheep is eternal life, with the assurance that they will never perish. No one can snatch them from His hand or from His Father’s hand. I find my security in the faithfulness and power of the Father and Son, rather than in the idea that I can keep a flawless record from this point onward.

That assurance belongs to those who are genuinely born again. Calling myself a Christian does not establish that I have received new life, and outward association with a church is not the same as belonging to Christ. But every genuine believer is permanently indwelt and sealed by the Holy Spirit and will never become eternally lost again.

The new birth produces a changed direction in life, so conduct can give evidence of that life without requiring sinless perfection. Jesus’ sheep follow Him because they belong to Him. Their following does not purchase the life He gives or become a continuing payment required to keep it. That helps us care for a wandering believer with both confidence in Christ’s promise and seriousness about the harm sin can do.

How the Church Should Care for Wanderers

James closes his letter by describing one person wandering from the truth and another helping him return. The person who strays is among the people James addresses as brethren, so this is a responsibility within the church’s own life. Someone’s departure from what is right must not make him cease to matter to those who know him.

Brethren, if anyone among you wanders from the truth, and someone turns him back, let him know that he who turns a sinner from the error of his way will save a soul from death and cover a multitude of sins.

James 5:19-20

James speaks about both the truth from which the person has wandered and the error of his way. False teaching and sinful conduct can become intertwined, so care requires enough attention to understand what has actually gone wrong. A warning may be necessary because love for the person includes concern for where his choices are taking him. If I dismiss every correction as unloving, I can leave him without help he needs.

Christians have understood James’ words about saving a soul from death in more than one way. One understanding concerns physical death under God’s discipline. That is a real possibility for a believer who persists in sin, as Paul explains in 1 Corinthians 11:17–32. The Corinthians were treating the Lord’s Supper, the meal remembering Christ’s death, in a way that shamed the poor and disregarded its meaning. Paul connected weakness, sickness, and some deaths among them with the Lord’s judgment and called them to examine themselves.

Another understanding is that James describes rescuing someone from final death whose profession of faith within the congregation was not genuine. A person may be among believers without ever having been born again. Steven Cole explains both readings and favors this second understanding. I do not take either reading to require that a person who has truly received eternal life loses it. Both recognize a danger that calls for seeking the sinner’s return rather than dismissing his conduct as harmless.

Covering a multitude of sins concerns the forgiveness connected with that return. It is not an instruction to hide wrongdoing so that an offender avoids accountability. The purpose is to bring the person back to what is true and right. Someone who helps serves in God’s work of restoration; he does not become another savior, and helping someone else does not earn forgiveness for his own sins.

Qualified male elders have a particular duty to shepherd a church. In 1 Peter 5:1–4, Peter, one of Jesus’ apostles, tells elders to care for God’s flock willingly and to be examples rather than lords over the people entrusted to them. The qualifications in 1 Timothy 3:1–7 and Titus 1:5–9 require character and faithfulness, not merely a desire to hold authority. The people belong to God, and the elders serve under Christ.

That responsibility does not mean everyone else must remain silent when a warning or encouragement is needed. James describes someone turning the wanderer back without restricting that care to an officeholder. Paul likewise calls believers to restore a person overtaken in sin with gentleness, while watching their own susceptibility to temptation, in Galatians 6:1. The person trying to help also needs the Shepherd’s care.

A patient conversation can make room for someone to explain what has happened. We can ask questions, pray, and bring Scripture to bear on the actual issue instead of beginning with a public accusation. Sometimes practical help is needed alongside correction. Someone who is struggling may need repeated instruction or help carrying a burden, and our willingness to give that help should be as real as our willingness to point out what is wrong.

Listening may also reveal that our first conclusion was mistaken. Leaving a particular congregation is not necessarily wandering from Christ. Someone may have left because of abuse, and pressuring that person to return to the same situation would misrepresent the Shepherd’s care. We should not threaten people, persist in unwanted contact, or ignore lawful boundaries under the claim that we are trying to restore them. Human leaders can teach and plead; they cannot control another person’s heart.

The rest of the flock also needs protection. Seeking one person does not justify exposing others to further harm, and rejoicing in repentance does not automatically remove safeguards or restore an offender to a former position. Reporting a crime and protecting those harmed can remain necessary. Forgiveness must not be used to silence them. Jesus’ warning about the little ones governs the way we seek recovery, as well as our reason for seeking it.

Peter also explains how the Shepherd’s suffering teaches His people to respond when they are wronged. In 1 Peter 2, he had been addressing servants who could suffer under harsh masters, distinguishing suffering for wrongdoing from suffering while doing what was right. He then pointed to Christ, whose innocence and response to mistreatment give believers an example to follow.

For to this you were called, because Christ also suffered for us, leaving us an example, that you should follow His steps: “Who committed no sin, Nor was deceit found in His mouth”; who, when He was reviled, did not revile in return; when He suffered, He did not threaten, but committed Himself to Him who judges righteously; who Himself bore our sins in His own body on the tree, that we, having died to sins, might live for righteousness–by whose stripes you were healed. For you were like sheep going astray, but have now returned to the Shepherd and Overseer of your souls.

1 Peter 2:21-25

Jesus committed no sin and spoke no deceit, yet He endured abuse without returning insults or threats. He entrusted Himself to the One who judges righteously. That response does not make the people who harmed Him innocent. It shows why His people can refuse personal revenge while trusting God to judge rightly.

Peter also says that Christ bore our sins in His body on the tree so that we might live for righteousness. The tree refers to the cross on which He died. His saving work has a purpose for the lives of those He brings back: people who had wandered like sheep now belong to the Shepherd and Overseer of their souls. An overseer exercises watchful care and authority. We have someone to trust and follow rather than remaining without direction.

Jesus is the eternal, uncreated Son of God, fully God and fully man. He was born of a virgin and was completely sinless. His atonement rests on that perfection and His voluntary offering of Himself to be slain as the perfect sacrifice. Wicked men tortured and crucified Him, and He willingly shed His innocent blood and died for us.

His saving sacrifice through His blood and death was complete before His burial, and He rose bodily from the dead. The Father did not punish, curse, abandon, strike, or bruise Jesus, and He did not pour wrath upon Him. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are distinct divine Persons who acted in perfect unity in our salvation. The Shepherd’s willing sacrifice must not be rewritten as the Father turning against His Son.

Christ died for the sins of the whole world, and His invitation is genuine for every person, even though people can resist His grace. Peter’s second letter explains why the time God gives people should be understood as an opportunity to respond. He describes scoffers asking why Christ has not returned and treating the continuation of the world as proof that His promise will not be fulfilled. Peter answers that complaint by explaining God’s patience.

But, beloved, do not forget this one thing, that with the Lord one day is as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day. The Lord is not slack concerning His promise, as some count slackness, but is longsuffering toward us, not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance.

2 Peter 3:8-9

The Lord has not forgotten His promise or become unable to carry it out. He is patient and desires repentance. Peter goes on to warn that judgment will come, so the present opportunity is not a guarantee that someone can safely put off responding forever. The God who seeks the lost is giving people reason to turn to Him now.

Everyone who comes to Jesus in repentance and faith receives forgiveness and justification, God’s declaration that the believer is righteous before Him. God gives that person new birth, and the Holy Spirit permanently indwells and seals him. Obedience follows from that life; it does not earn salvation or keep us saved. A profession without genuine faith and repentance is not proof of conversion.

Having received that mercy, I have no reason to defend my own rebellion or resent another person’s welcome. The Shepherd has not treated me as disposable, and His care gives me a reason to seek the good of someone who has wandered. Truthful correction, protection from harm, and joy over genuine repentance all belong within that care.

My Final Thoughts

In Luke, the shepherd’s celebration confronts people who resent mercy being shown to sinners. In Matthew, his search confronts disciples who might overlook one of the little ones their Father values. Both passages make me consider whether my response to another person reflects the care Jesus has described.

I cannot receive the parable faithfully while refusing to turn from my own sin, and I cannot honor its teaching by leaving a wanderer without concern. The Shepherd gave His life for us and keeps those who are genuinely His. Under His care, I can speak truthfully, seek someone’s return with patience, protect those who could be harmed, and rejoice when that person comes back.