Christophanies in the Old Testament: Was Jesus There?

by Joshua Andreasen | Founder of Unforsaken

If we open our Bibles and read about Moses and the burning bush in Exodus 3, we find something curious about the One speaking to him. Verse 2 says the Angel of the LORD appeared in the flame, but as Moses approached, the One speaking identified Himself as the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. If this was an angel, why did He identify Himself as God, and why was Moses afraid to look at Him?

I believe Moses was speaking with Jesus Christ, the eternal Son of God, long before His birth in Bethlehem. I came to that conclusion by comparing what happened at the burning bush with what the New Testament tells us about the Son. I want to begin with that encounter, because it helps explain why I recognize Christ in several other Old Testament passages where people met the LORD.

Who Was Speaking from the Bush?

Moses was tending the flock of his father-in-law Jethro when he brought the sheep to Horeb and noticed a bush burning without being consumed. He turned aside to see why it was not burning up, and as he approached, God called his name from the bush. Although verse 2 introduces the Angel of the LORD, verse 4 calls the One speaking God. Nothing in the account describes one speaker leaving and another taking His place. Moses is approaching the same bush and responding to the One who has called him.

Then He said, “Do not draw near this place. Take your sandals off your feet, for the place where you stand is holy ground.”

Exodus 3:5, NKJV

As the conversation continues, God tells Moses who He is, naming Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob as the men whose God He has been. Moses then hides his face because he is afraid to look at God. His response agrees with what the Speaker has said about Himself. He understands that he is in God’s presence, which also explains why he has been told to remove his sandals.

To understand why the passage introduces Him as an Angel, I need to explain how Scripture uses that word. Angel means messenger, so the word tells us that someone has been sent. It does not, by itself, settle the question of who has been sent. Before we decide who the Messenger is, we need to read what He says and how the passage identifies Him. At the bush, those details identify Him as the God who made His covenant with Abraham and his descendants.

Scripture tells us that God created angelic beings, and the angels who serve Him understand that they are His messengers and that He alone is God. We can see this in Revelation 22:8–9, when John falls down to worship the angel who has shown him the visions. The angel stops him because he is a fellow servant, and he tells John to worship God. He knows who deserves the worship John is offering, so he directs John to the One he serves.

If we compare that encounter with what happened to Moses, we can see why we need to read what each Messenger says about Himself. The angel speaking to John identifies himself as a servant of God, whereas the One speaking to Moses identifies Himself as God. We cannot treat those declarations as though they mean the same thing simply because both passages use the word angel.

An appearance of God is called a theophany, and when the Person appearing is Christ before He became man, we call it a Christophany. That is how I understand the encounter at the burning bush. Exodus identifies the Speaker as God; to explain why I believe He is the Son, I want to compare that identification with John’s account of who Jesus is.

The Son Was Already There Before Bethlehem

John begins his Gospel by taking us back before Jesus’ birth and even before the creation of the world. He tells us that the Word was with God and that the Word was God, then explains that everything that was made came into existence through Him (John 1:1–3). When we reach verse 14, John says this same Word became flesh and lived among us. The One who entered the world as a man was therefore already its Creator.

This is why I understand Bethlehem as the beginning of the Son’s human life, while recognizing that He had always existed with the Father. When He took a true human nature, He remained fully God, and He continues to be fully God and fully man. We call this the incarnation. His appearances in the Old Testament occurred before that incarnation, so recognizing Him in those passages does not mean that His birth had somehow already taken place.

If we continue to John 1:18, we find an explanation of the Son’s relationship to the Father that helps us understand how people such as Moses could encounter God:

No one has seen God at any time. The only begotten Son, who is in the bosom of the Father, He has declared Him.

John 1:18, NKJV

If we stop after the first sentence, we might wonder how Moses could have been afraid to look at God or how Abraham could have spoken with Him. But John continues by telling us that the Son has made Him known. Jesus spoke specifically of the Father in John 5:37 when He said, “You have neither heard His voice at any time, nor seen His form.” I understand those statements together: the Father is made known through the Son, and it is through the Son that I believe Moses and Abraham encountered God.

That understanding also agrees with Colossians 1:15–17, which describes Christ as the image of the invisible God and says that all things were created through Him, including the heavenly beings. Because He created the angels, He already existed before they did. Hebrews 1:3 describes Him as the brightness of God’s glory and the express image of His person, and verse 6 calls the angels to worship Him. Their worship belongs to Him because He is God, even when He comes as the Messenger sent by the Father.

I am speaking here of the Father and Son as distinct Persons within the one God. The Holy Spirit is also fully divine, so the one God eternally exists as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. This is what I mean by the Trinity. Understanding that personal distinction allows me to recognize the Son as God while also understanding that the Father sends Him.

Jesus Himself spoke of His existence before Abraham in John 8:58. Since Abraham lived many centuries before Jesus’ birth, His words give us a reason to look back at Abraham’s life knowing that the Son was already there. Genesis records several encounters from that period, beginning with a priest who came to meet Abraham after a battle.

The Priest Who Came to Meet Abram

In Genesis 14, Abraham is still called Abram, and his nephew Lot has been carried away by an invading army along with other captives and goods from Sodom. When Abram hears what has happened, he gathers men from his household and pursues the captors. He recovers Lot, the other people, and their possessions, and it is while he is returning from that rescue that Melchizedek comes to meet him.

Then Melchizedek king of Salem brought out bread and wine; he was the priest of God Most High.

Genesis 14:18, NKJV

Melchizedek blesses Abram and praises God Most High for delivering Abram’s enemies into his hand, after which Abram gives him a tenth of the spoils. If we had only these few verses in Genesis, there would be much about this priest that we could not explain. But Psalm 110:4 later speaks of the Messiah as a priest forever according to the order of Melchizedek, and Hebrews 7 returns to the meeting with Abram to explain that priesthood.

In Hebrews, Paul begins with Melchizedek’s name, which means king of righteousness, and his title as king of Salem, which means king of peace. He then describes him without father or mother, without genealogy, and without beginning of days or end of life. Hebrews 7:3 says he is “made like the Son of God” and remains a priest continually. I believe Melchizedek is the preincarnate God the Son, and the description of his continuing life is central to why I understand him that way.

As Paul develops the argument, verse 8 contrasts mortal men who receive tithes with the one of whom it is witnessed that he lives. If we read that statement alongside the description in verse 3 and the promise of an everlasting priesthood in Psalm 110, we find that all three passages speak of a priest whose service continues. I understand that continuing priesthood to rest on His life never ending, which agrees with what Scripture tells us about the eternal Son.

Abraham’s response helps explain the authority of this priest. Although Abraham was the man who had received God’s promises, he accepted Melchizedek’s blessing and gave him a tenth. Hebrews 7:7 explains that the one giving the blessing is greater than the one receiving it. So when we return to Abraham’s meeting with Melchizedek, we can see why receiving that blessing meant acknowledging someone greater than himself, even though God had already given Abraham such an important place in His promises.

Paul then explains how this meeting relates to Israel’s later priesthood. Levi would be one of Abraham’s descendants, and the priests who served Israel would come from Levi’s family. Although Levi had not yet been born when Abraham met Melchizedek, Paul includes him in his ancestor’s act of paying tithes. The family that would eventually receive tithes from Israel had therefore paid tithes through Abraham to Melchizedek. That is how Paul explains the superiority of Melchizedek’s priesthood over the priesthood inherited through Levi.

I recognize Christ in this encounter because the explanation reaches beyond the authority of an ordinary priest whose service ends at death. Hebrews describes a continuing priesthood, Abraham acknowledges its superiority, and Psalm 110 promises that the Messiah will hold that priesthood forever. I explain the connection further in my study on Melchizedek.

For me, the assurance in this passage becomes especially clear in Hebrews 7:23–25. Israel’s priests died and had to be replaced, but Christ continues forever and lives to intercede for those who come to God through Him. Because His life continues, I can depend on His intercession. The Savior through whom I approach God today will never need someone else to take His place.

The LORD Meets a Servant and Visits Abraham

The same household appears again in Genesis 16, where Abram’s wife Sarai has borne him no children. Hoping to have a family through her Egyptian servant Hagar, she gives Hagar to Abram. But after Hagar becomes pregnant, the relationship between the two women deteriorates, and Sarai treats her so harshly that she runs away (Genesis 16:1–6).

It is while Hagar is away from that household that the Angel of the LORD finds her beside a spring in the wilderness. He calls her by name and asks where she has come from and where she is going. When she explains that she is fleeing Sarai, He tells her to return and submit to her mistress. Along with that command, He speaks about the son she will bear, names him Ishmael, and promises to multiply her descendants (Genesis 16:7–12).

I recognize the same kind of identification here that we saw at the burning bush. The passage begins by naming the Angel of the LORD, but Genesis 16:13 calls the One speaking to Hagar the LORD, and she addresses Him as “You-Are-the-God-Who-Sees.” Her response follows what He has done: He has found her in the wilderness, heard her answer, and spoken about the future of her unborn son.

What I appreciate about this encounter is that His attention extends to Hagar herself. The household she fled belonged to the man who had received God’s promises, yet the LORD came to her in the painful circumstances that had developed within it. As we read His promise to her, we can see His care for a woman whose suffering He knew. That care helps me understand the character of the One I am identifying as the Son.

By Genesis 18, God has changed Abram’s name to Abraham and Sarai’s to Sarah. Abraham is sitting at the entrance of his tent by the trees of Mamre when he sees three men and runs to meet them. He asks them to rest while he brings food, then has Sarah prepare bread and a servant prepare a calf. After setting the meal before his visitors, he stands nearby while they eat.

Genesis introduces this visit by saying that the LORD appeared to Abraham, and during their conversation the LORD promises that Sarah will have a son. When the visitors leave, Abraham accompanies them, and the LORD speaks with him about Sodom. Two of the visitors continue to the city, where Genesis 19:1 identifies them as angels, while Abraham remains before the LORD to ask about the judgment that is coming.

Abraham wants to know whether the righteous will perish with the wicked, so he appeals to the justice of the One he is addressing: “Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?” (Genesis 18:25). I understand the visitor to be the Son because Genesis identifies Him as the LORD and John explains that the Son makes the Father known. The conversation also shows Abraham addressing Him as the One who has authority to judge the city. He has received this visitor at his tent, and now he is asking Him about the exercise of divine judgment.

Years later, in Genesis 22, Abraham hears the Angel of the LORD call to him from heaven when he is about to offer Isaac. God had commanded the offering of the very son through whom He had promised Abraham descendants. As Abraham reaches for the knife, the Angel stops him, and Abraham then offers a ram caught by its horns in a thicket. Isaac is spared, and the son through whom God made His promise remains alive.

The Angel calls to Abraham again after the offering and declares, “By Myself I have sworn, says the LORD” (Genesis 22:16). I understand this oath by comparing it with Hebrews 6:13, which explains that God swore by Himself because there was no one greater by whom He could swear. The pledge belongs to God Himself. Although this encounter is a voice from heaven rather than a visitor standing before Abraham, the words once again connect the Angel with the LORD who made the promise.

Jacob Wrestles, and Israel Learns to Obey

The promise continues through Abraham’s family, and in Genesis 32 his grandson Jacob encounters God as he prepares to meet his brother Esau. Esau had wanted to kill him years earlier, so when Jacob learns that his brother is approaching with four hundred men, he is afraid. He prays and sends gifts ahead before taking his family across the stream. After he is left alone that night, a Man wrestles with him until daybreak.

During the struggle, the Man touches Jacob’s hip and puts it out of joint, but Jacob continues to hold on and asks for a blessing before he will let go. He receives that blessing along with the new name Israel. Afterward, Jacob names the place Peniel because, as he explains, “I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved” (Genesis 32:30). Hosea 12:3–5 later describes this struggle in terms of Jacob contending with the Angel and identifies the LORD God of hosts.

I came to understand this as another encounter with the Son by comparing Jacob’s explanation with what Hosea says about the same event. If we look again at the struggle itself, the Man could put Jacob’s hip out of joint with a touch, which shows how little the outcome depended on Jacob’s physical strength. He held on because he wanted a blessing, and the LORD gave it to him. I see God dealing with Jacob’s reliance on himself, allowing him to continue toward his meeting with Esau as a blessed man who now walked with a limp.

Jacob’s descendants eventually became the people enslaved in Egypt, so we can now return to the burning bush with more of their family history before us. When God identified Himself to Moses as the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, He was naming men with whom He had already dealt personally. He told Moses that He had seen the oppression of their descendants and heard their cries, and He was sending Moses to bring them out. Their deliverance would fulfill His covenant with the family we have been following through Genesis.

After Israel came out of Egypt, the LORD promised that His Angel would go ahead of them toward the land He had prepared. Because His name was in this Angel, the people were commanded to obey Him (Exodus 23:20–21). I understand that command as part of the same relationship: the God who delivered Israel was leading them toward the land He had promised, and they were responsible for listening to Him as they went.

The Commander and the Men Who Feared They Would Die

As Israel prepared to fight at Jericho, Joshua encountered a Man standing with a drawn sword. He approached and asked whether the Man was for Israel or its enemies, but the answer identified Him as Commander of the army of the LORD. Once Joshua heard who He was, he fell on his face, worshiped, and asked what his Lord had to say to His servant (Joshua 5:13–14).

The Commander then told Joshua to remove his sandal because the ground was holy. I recognize the connection to Moses here because the same command had been given when God called him to lead Israel out of Egypt. Joshua was now leading the people in the promised land, and the One before him accepted his worship and declared the ground holy. Those details are why I believe Joshua was meeting Christ, even though this passage does not use the title Angel of the LORD.

Joshua’s response also gives me something to consider about my own obedience. He approached wanting to know whose side the Man was on, but after learning His identity, he asked for instructions. If I come to Christ asking Him to support plans I have already made, I need to be willing to hear what He wants me to do. His authority includes the right to change those plans, and asking for His direction means being prepared to follow it.

Israel’s later conduct shows how easily people can receive God’s provision and still refuse His commands. In Judges 2, after they have entered and settled in the land, the Angel of the LORD confronts them for failing to tear down the altars of its inhabitants. He reminds them that He brought them out of Egypt and into the land He had sworn to give their fathers, calling the covenant His own. Their disobedience was therefore against the One who had kept His promise to them.

This is another reason I identify the divine Angel of the LORD as the Son. He claims the covenant and the deliverance as His work, which connects His words in Judges with His dealings with Abraham and Moses. I examine those passages further in my study on The Angel of the Lord.

By the time we reach Gideon in Judges 6, Israel is suffering under Midianite oppression. Gideon is beating out wheat in a winepress to keep it hidden from the Midianites when the Angel of the LORD comes to call him to deliver Israel. Gideon objects that his family is the weakest in Manasseh and that he is the least in his father’s house. The LORD answers his concern by promising to be with him, giving him a reason to act that does not depend on the standing of his family.

During this conversation, the passage identifies the Speaker as the LORD, and Gideon’s later response shows his fear when he realizes whom he has seen. He brings an offering, which the Angel touches with His staff, and fire rises from the rock to consume it. After the Angel departs, Gideon fears for his life because he has seen Him face to face, but the LORD reassures him that he will live (Judges 6:20–23). I see the same God who commissions Gideon also answering the fear that could keep him from obeying.

Manoah expresses a similar fear in Judges 13 after the Angel of the LORD visits his family. The Angel first appears to his wife, who has been unable to have children, and tells her that she will bear the son we know as Samson. When He appears again and Manoah offers to prepare food, the Angel tells him that if he prepares a burnt offering, he must offer it to the LORD.

As the flame rises from that offering, the Angel ascends in it, and Manoah and his wife fall on their faces. Manoah is convinced that they will die because they have seen God. His wife answers by considering why the LORD came to them in the first place: He has announced the birth of their son and accepted their offering. If He intended to kill them, she reasons, He would not have received the offering or told them what He had.

I appreciate the way she works through her husband’s fear using what God has actually said and done. She has witnessed the same encounter, but she also remembers the promise that accompanied it. Because God has spoken about their child’s future, she has a reason to expect them to live. Her confidence follows the evidence He has given her.

The Glory Isaiah Saw and the Deliverer in the Fire

In the passages we have examined so far, the words and actions of the One appearing help us identify Him. Isaiah’s vision gives us a further connection because John later explains whose glory Isaiah saw. In Isaiah 6, the prophet sees the Lord seated on a throne, high and lifted up, while the seraphim proclaim His holiness. Having seen the King, the LORD of hosts, Isaiah is distressed by his own unclean lips and those of the people among whom he lives.

Before Isaiah receives his commission, one of the seraphim brings a coal from the altar and touches his mouth, telling him that his iniquity is taken away. The prophet is cleansed and then hears the LORD’s call. When John later explains why people refused to believe in Jesus despite the signs He had done, he quotes Isaiah’s words about unbelief and the hardened response described in that commission. He then identifies the One of whom Isaiah was speaking:

These things Isaiah said when he saw His glory and spoke of Him.

John 12:41, NKJV

Because John is speaking about Jesus, I understand him to be identifying the glory Isaiah saw as Christ’s glory. Here the New Testament directly connects Jesus with the Lord seen in an Old Testament vision. The Son who later lived among the people of John’s day already possessed that glory when Isaiah saw Him centuries before His birth.

Later in Israel’s history, Shadrach, Meshach, and Abed-Nego faced death in Babylon for refusing to worship Nebuchadnezzar’s golden image. They told the king that God was able to deliver them, but they would still refuse to bow even if He did not. Their obedience was already settled when Nebuchadnezzar ordered them bound and thrown into the furnace (Daniel 3).

After they were thrown in, the king saw four men walking in the fire, unbound and unharmed, and described the fourth as “like the Son of God” (Daniel 3:25). The three men he had condemned then came out alive, and he acknowledged that their God had sent His Angel to deliver them. I believe that fourth Man was Christ, appearing with His servants in the danger they had faced because they would not worship another god.

I came to that conclusion by comparing this deliverance with the other occasions when the Son came to His people in their distress. In Isaiah’s case, John explicitly identifies the glory the prophet saw with Christ; here, Daniel records Nebuchadnezzar’s description, which I understand alongside those other encounters. That is the reasoning behind my identification of the fourth Man.

I do not use the presence of an angel alone to make that identification in every account. For example, Daniel 6 says that God sent an angel to shut the lions’ mouths, but it supplies no further description that identifies that messenger as Christ. As we saw with the angel who spoke to John, God also sends created servants to carry out His work. As we read these accounts, we need to consider what each passage tells us about its messenger before deciding who appeared.

The Lord Who Removes Guilt

After the exile, Zechariah saw a vision in which the Angel of the LORD dealt with the guilt of Joshua the high priest. This Joshua lived long after the Joshua who led Israel into Canaan, and his priestly office is part of what makes the vision so revealing. Although he stood as high priest, his garments were filthy, and Satan stood there to accuse him. The LORD rebuked Satan, and the Angel commanded those nearby to remove Joshua’s filthy clothing (Zechariah 3:1–4).

The Angel explained the removal of those garments by telling Joshua, “See, I have removed your iniquity from you, and I will clothe you with rich robes” (Zechariah 3:4). I understand the clothing in the vision as a picture of Joshua’s guilt because the Angel Himself connects changing the garments with removing his iniquity. Holding the office of high priest did not remove Joshua’s need for cleansing, and the Angel declared that cleansing to be His own work.

Zechariah had already heard this Angel speak on behalf of Jerusalem, asking the LORD of hosts how long the city would have to wait for mercy (Zechariah 1:12). I understand His intercession through the personal distinction between the Father and Son that we considered earlier. The Son can address the Father while exercising divine authority Himself. His work on behalf of His people agrees with what the New Testament tells us about Him as our Advocate and Mediator.

As we consider His words about removing Joshua’s guilt, I want to connect them with the sacrifice He would later provide for sinners. The eternal Son became man, lived without sin, and willingly offered Himself for our sins. Wicked men mocked Him, beat Him, and crucified Him, but the Father did not punish or abandon His Son. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit were united in providing the salvation we receive through Christ.

Because Jesus was sinless, He could give Himself as the perfect sacrifice for us, and His shed blood and death accomplished our atonement. That sacrifice was complete when He died, before His burial and bodily resurrection. He then rose from the dead and lives as the Savior through whom we are reconciled to God. I can therefore understand the cleansing announced to Joshua in relation to the Son who would give His own life for our sins.

Christ died for the whole world, and His invitation to repent and believe is sincere, even though people can resist His grace and refuse Him. Those who come to Him in repentance and faith are born again, indwelt and sealed by the Holy Spirit, and secure in the life He gives. Because that life comes from Him, it bears fruit in obedience. I depend on Christ both to save me and to keep me, and His mercy gives me reason to turn from the sin for which He died.

My Final Thoughts

We began by opening our Bibles to the burning bush and asking who spoke to Moses, and I believe these passages explain why we can recognize the Son there. The One who appeared was identified as God, and the New Testament tells us that the eternal Son makes the Father known. His existence before Bethlehem allows me to understand how He could already be dealing with Abraham and his descendants long before He became man.

As we follow those encounters, we also see what His presence required of the people He met. Moses had to return to Egypt, Joshua had to receive His instructions, and Gideon had to trust the promise that God would be with him. That gives me something to consider beyond identifying who appeared. If I recognize this same Lord as the One who saved me, then I also need to listen to what He says and be willing to obey Him.