Are Christians Required to Tithe? What the Bible Teaches

by Joshua Andreasen | Founder of Unforsaken

A tithe is a tenth, and God commanded Israel to give tithes under the Law He gave through Moses. I do not believe that Christians are required to give ten percent under that law, or that giving less places a believer under the judgment the prophet Malachi announced against Israel for withholding its tithes. The New Testament does call us to support faithful ministry and to help people in need. To understand how those responsibilities fit together, we have to look at whom God commanded to tithe and then compare those instructions with what He tells the church.

What Abram Gave to Melchizedek

Everything we have comes from God, and we are responsible to Him for how we use it. That is what I mean when I say that we are stewards. We are caring for what He has entrusted to us. The question is whether that responsibility places Christians under the same tithe arrangement that God later gave Israel through Moses.

The first recorded tithe comes before Moses, in the account of Abram’s rescue of Lot. Genesis 14 tells us that a group of kings had carried away people and possessions from Sodom, including Abram’s nephew Lot. Abram pursued them, defeated them, and brought back the captives and the goods. When he returned, the king of Sodom came out to meet him, and so did Melchizedek, the king of Salem.

Then Melchizedek king of Salem brought out bread and wine; he was the priest of God Most High. And he blessed him and said: “Blessed be Abram of God Most High, Possessor of heaven and earth; And blessed be God Most High, Who has delivered your enemies into your hand.” And he gave him a tithe of all.

Genesis 14:18-20

Notice what had happened before Abram gave the tenth. God had already delivered his enemies into his hand, and Melchizedek had already blessed him. Abram’s gift did not purchase the victory or persuade Melchizedek to bless him. He gave after receiving the deliverance for which God was being praised.

The king of Sodom then offered Abram the recovered goods, asking only for the people to be returned. Abram refused to keep those goods for himself because he did not want the king to be able to say that he had made Abram rich. He allowed for what his men had eaten and for the shares belonging to the men who had gone with him, but he would not take Sodom’s wealth as his own reward. His words kept the credit for his provision with the LORD.

A tithe is a tenth. The Hebrew word ma’aser expresses that amount, but knowing the percentage does not tell us what was being given or whether the gift was recurring. For that, we have to read the account around it. Hebrews 7:4 identifies Abram’s gift as a tenth of the spoils. We are looking at a gift connected to this victory, rather than an instruction about a regular payment from his household income.

I believe that Abram’s gift honored God, and I also believe we should be careful about making it say more than the passage says. Genesis records what Abram gave. It does not command every believer in every generation to give the same percentage, and it does not describe him making that payment every week or every year.

Melchizedek’s identity gives the encounter a further significance. I believe that he was the eternal Son appearing before His incarnation, which is what I mean by a Christophany. Hebrews describes him as king of righteousness and king of peace, without father, mother, or genealogy, and as remaining a priest continually. I understand that description to concern more than an ordinary king who happens to illustrate something about Christ. The study on Melchizedek explains how I came to that conclusion.

Jacob’s Promise at Bethel

Abram was later named Abraham, and his grandson Jacob also spoke of giving a tenth before the Law was given at Sinai. His circumstances were different from Abram’s. He had left home and was traveling toward Haran when God appeared to him at Bethel, confirmed the covenant promise of land and descendants, and promised to be with him and bring him back.

After hearing those promises, Jacob made a vow about what he would give from the provision he received.

Then Jacob made a vow, saying, “If God will be with me, and keep me in this way that I am going, and give me bread to eat and clothing to put on, so that I come back to my father’s house in peace, then the LORD shall be my God. And this stone which I have set as a pillar shall be God’s house, and of all that You give me I will surely give a tenth to You.”

Genesis 28:20-22

Jacob was looking ahead to the journey and to his return to his father’s house. He named the ordinary things he would need along the way, including food and clothing, and he promised a tenth of what God would give him. His vow acknowledged that his provision would come from the LORD.

But Jacob was making his own promise to God. The fact that Scripture records that promise does not turn it into a command addressed to the church. Abram gave after deliverance, and Jacob vowed to give as he looked ahead to God’s care. Both accounts belong in our understanding of giving, but neither one establishes the recurring obligation that would later be placed on Israel under Moses.

The Tithe God Commanded Israel to Bring

Under Moses, God gave the nation a command concerning its tithes. He had brought Israel out of Egypt, entered into covenant with the people, and instructed them about life in the land He was giving them. The tithe belonged within that national arrangement, with an appointed sanctuary and people set apart to serve there.

And all the tithe of the land, whether of the seed of the land or of the fruit of the tree, is the LORD’s. It is holy to the LORD.

Leviticus 27:30

Leviticus speaks about the seed of the land and the fruit of the trees. The instructions that follow also address the herds and flocks. These were provisions from the land God had given Israel, and He declared the tithe holy to Himself.

There was even provision for the practical difficulty of carrying those goods a long distance. In Deuteronomy 14:24–26, an Israelite who could not carry the tithe on the journey could exchange it for money. He would take the money to the place God chose, buy provisions there, and eat before the LORD with his household.

The money served a particular purpose in that instruction. It allowed the person to make the journey without transporting all the produce or animals, and then to obtain what was needed at the destination. I do not think we can take the mention of money and treat it as though Moses had given a rule about every worker’s paycheck in every society. The command was still describing Israel’s worship and provision from its land.

Numbers explains why the Levites, the descendants of Jacob’s son Levi, received the tithes. God had set them apart for the work of the tabernacle, the portable sanctuary where Israel worshiped Him, and they would not receive an ordinary tribal territory like the other tribes.

“Behold, I have given the children of Levi all the tithes in Israel as an inheritance in return for the work which they perform, the work of the tabernacle of meeting.”

Numbers 18:21

The other tribes would receive territorial inheritances, while the Levites would be supported in the service God had assigned them. Aaron’s family supplied the priests, and the other Levitical families performed the duties given to them around the tabernacle. The Levites also taught God’s Law, and they were commanded to give a tenth from the tithes they received. God had provided for both their work and their support.

Deuteronomy also connects the tithe with rejoicing before the LORD and learning to fear Him. The household was to eat before Him with gratitude, and the Levite was not to be forgotten. At the end of every third year, the provision was to be stored within the towns so that those who needed it could come and eat.

“At the end of every third year you shall bring out the tithe of your produce of that year and store it up within your gates. And the Levite, because he has no portion nor inheritance with you, and the stranger and the fatherless and the widow who are within your gates, may come and eat and be satisfied, that the LORD your God may bless you in all the work of your hand which you do.”

Deuteronomy 14:28-29

That command names people whose needs the rest of Israel was responsible to remember. The Levite lacked the same territorial inheritance, and the stranger, the fatherless, and the widow could be without the support available to other households. God intended this provision to feed them until they were satisfied.

So when we talk about Israel’s tithe, we are talking about more than a percentage taken out of context. We are reading about the support of sacred service, worship before the LORD, and food for people in need within a covenant nation. Taking the tenth while leaving out the inheritance and responsibilities attached to it would not reproduce the arrangement God gave through Moses.

Who Was Robbing God in Malachi?

That covenant setting helps us understand Malachi’s rebuke. The people were withholding what God had commanded them to bring, and He called their refusal robbery. Listen to whom He addresses in the passage.

“Will a man rob God? Yet you have robbed Me! But you say, ‘In what way have we robbed You?’ In tithes and offerings. You are cursed with a curse, For you have robbed Me, Even this whole nation. Bring all the tithes into the storehouse, That there may be food in My house, And try Me now in this,” Says the LORD of hosts, “If I will not open for you the windows of heaven And pour out for you such blessing That there will not be room enough to receive it.”

Malachi 3:8-10

God speaks of the whole nation. He also says that the tithes were to be brought into the storehouse so that there would be food in His house. These words concern Israel’s covenant obligations and the provision for temple service. The blessing and the curse belonged to the covenant under which that nation lived.

Malachi was confronting more than a shortage in the storehouse. The book also rebukes corrupt priests, marital unfaithfulness, and injustice. The people and their leaders were accountable to God for the way they were living, and withholding the tithes and offerings was part of that unfaithfulness. We should hear the seriousness of the rebuke in the setting in which God gave it.

That is why I would not tell a Christian who gives less than ten percent that Malachi has placed him under a curse. A church building is not Israel’s temple storehouse, and the believer is not living under the Mosaic covenant. We can learn from God’s rebuke of unfaithfulness without transferring Israel’s covenant penalty to someone the passage does not address.

The same care is needed whenever we apply a biblical command. Before telling someone what a passage requires of him, we have to establish who received the command and how it relates to the covenant under which he lives. The study on how to study the Bible properly examines that responsibility.

Christ redeemed believers from the curse of the Law through His willing sacrifice and shed blood. The curse concerned lawbreakers, and He came to rescue us. I do not understand that redemption to mean that the Father cursed His Son. Father and Son were united in the work of saving us.

A pastor should not use Malachi to threaten people bought by Christ’s blood with the covenant curse from which He redeemed them. The church must still teach generosity and call selfishness what it is, but it should do so from the instructions God has given us. Fear of a misapplied curse is not the foundation of Christian giving.

The Priesthood Has Changed

The difference between Israel’s tithe system and Christian giving cannot be explained simply by saying that we now live in a different economy. The priesthood itself has changed. Jesus is our eternal High Priest according to the order of Melchizedek, and His sacrifice accomplished what the animal offerings anticipated.

Therefore, if perfection were through the Levitical priesthood (for under it the people received the law), what further need was there that another priest should rise according to the order of Melchizedek, and not be called according to the order of Aaron? For the priesthood being changed, of necessity there is also a change of the law.

Hebrews 7:11-12

Paul explains in Hebrews that the Levitical priesthood could not bring the perfection that comes through Christ. If it could, there would have been no need for the priesthood described in the promise concerning Melchizedek. The passage therefore connects the change in priesthood with a change in the law governing that priesthood.

Abram’s tithe is part of that argument. Melchizedek received the tenth and blessed Abram, and Hebrews says that the lesser is blessed by the greater. Levi had not yet been born, but he would descend from Abraham. In that sense, Hebrews treats Levi as having paid tithes through his ancestor. The men who later received tithes under the Law descended from a man who had given a tenth to Melchizedek and received his blessing.

I understand the point to be the greatness of Melchizedek’s priesthood and, through that comparison, the greatness of Christ’s priesthood. Hebrews does not turn Abram’s gift into an instruction for churches to collect ten percent. It uses the gift to explain why the Levitical priesthood cannot claim a higher standing than the priesthood being described.

Because Christ has offered the final sacrifice, we no longer bring animals to the sanctuary or depend on Levitical priests for access to the Father. Jesus is our one Mediator, the One through whom we come to God. We should recognize the same fulfillment when we consider the system that supported that priesthood. I do not believe that continuing Israel’s temple economy is a condition of God’s favor toward the church.

What, then, did Jesus mean when He told the Pharisees, a group of Jewish religious leaders, that they should tithe? He spoke to them during His ministry before the cross, while they were living under the Law. They were carefully measuring the tithe on small herbs while neglecting the weightier matters of that same Law.

“Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you pay tithe of mint and anise and cummin, and have neglected the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy and faith. These you ought to have done, without leaving the others undone.”

Matthew 23:23

Jesus did not excuse these men from the command God had given them. He told them to attend to justice, mercy, and faith without neglecting their other obligations. Their careful calculation of the tithe did not make up for the way they were failing to obey God in the rest of their lives.

His rebuke does not put the church under Israel’s covenant, but I can see how the same hypocrisy could appear in my own life. I could give an impressive amount and then point to it while mistreating my family or cheating someone in business. The donation would not make that conduct acceptable. Giving cannot buy forgiveness or make rebellion harmless. Only Christ’s blood cleanses sin.

What the Apostles Told Believers to Give

When we read the instructions given to the church, we find believers being called to meet real needs. Paul organized a collection for needy believers in Jerusalem, and he wanted the Corinthians to prepare for it before he arrived. His instruction gave them a regular way to set aside their gifts.

On the first day of the week let each one of you lay something aside, storing up as he may prosper, that there be no collections when I come.

1 Corinthians 16:2

Each person was to lay something aside according to how he prospered. Paul was asking them to prepare, so that the collection would not depend on a hurried appeal when he arrived. That gives us a practical way to think about our own giving. If I spend everything as it comes in, a need I sincerely want to help with may arrive when I have nothing left to give.

Setting something aside requires me to consider what I can afford and what I am choosing to spend on myself. Paul’s reference to how each person prospers also recognizes that circumstances differ. One household may be struggling to pay for necessities, while another has received an increase in income. Planning gives each household an opportunity to consider those circumstances before God and then follow through.

In 2 Corinthians 8–9, Paul returned to the relief effort and urged the Corinthians to complete what they had begun. He described the generosity of the Macedonian believers, who had given willingly despite their deep poverty. They first gave themselves to the Lord, and their gifts followed that commitment. Paul wanted the Corinthians’ promised help to become an actual provision for the people who needed it.

So let each one give as he purposes in his heart, not grudgingly or of necessity; for God loves a cheerful giver.

2 Corinthians 9:7

The decision was to be made in the giver’s heart. Paul did not tell church leaders to threaten people or embarrass them into participating. I do not see how public humiliation or a warning that God will curse someone for giving too little can be reconciled with the willingness he describes here.

Willingness does not mean that a gift will cost us nothing. A believer can be glad to help and still feel the sacrifice involved in parting with money the household could have used. The difference is that the person is choosing to give, rather than having the gift extracted through pressure.

Paul also speaks about sowing and reaping in this passage, but his explanation concerns provision for good works and generosity toward others. God supplies what enables His people to give, and the help they provide leads to thanksgiving to Him. I do not understand that as a promise that a donation will return a financial profit to the donor. Turning it into that promise changes the purpose of the giving Paul is describing.

Relief for the poor is one responsibility, and supporting those who teach the Word is another. Paul tells believers to share with the people who teach them.

Let him who is taught the word share in all good things with him who teaches.

Galatians 6:6

He also says in 1 Timothy 5:17–18 that elders who rule well are worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in the Word and doctrine. A teacher who gives his time to studying Scripture and caring for the congregation still has material needs. Supporting him helps make that work possible.

That support should sustain faithful ministry. It should not reward spiritual showmanship or place a leader beyond reasonable questions. Those entrusted with gifts are responsible to handle them honestly and to explain how they are being used. Asking where the money goes is not, by itself, an attack on the work of God.

Acts 5 gives us another useful distinction. Believers were sharing their possessions to meet needs, and Ananias sold a possession but lied about the amount he brought. Peter told him that the property had been his before it was sold and that the money remained under his control after the sale. His sin was lying to God, not failing to obey a command that every believer must surrender everything.

I think that helps us hold two things together. The sharing was voluntary, and honesty before God was still required. The Holy Spirit was producing generosity among the believers, but that did not make deception about a gift acceptable. We should encourage the same willingness while taking our responsibility for truthfulness seriously.

Making Room to Give in Everyday Life

After recognizing that the church is not under the tithe law, I still have to ask what I am doing with the resources God has entrusted to me. Freedom from that law does not make everything I earn available for selfish use. If I can help someone and simply refuse because I would rather keep everything for myself, I cannot use this study as an excuse.

That examination starts with the responsibilities already in front of me. I have a duty to provide for my household and to honor legitimate debts. Giving in public while neglecting those obligations would not make me generous in God’s sight. Honest work and contentment help me care for the people entrusted to me and also make room to help others.

For someone learning to plan, setting aside a tenth may be a useful habit. I have no objection to a believer choosing that amount. But a chosen habit is different from a law imposed on every Christian, and the percentage should not become a ceiling for someone who is able to do more.

The same percentage can have very different effects on two households. For one family, it may involve a substantial sacrifice. For another, it may scarcely affect the amount available for personal spending. I think we should consider our actual circumstances, the needs we know about, and the responsibilities God has given us rather than assume that reaching a number settles every question about faithfulness.

The local church that faithfully teaches and cares for us should receive consistent support. We should also consider the teaching and conduct of any ministry asking for help. A request for money does not establish that the work deserves our trust. Prayer and reasonable questions about what is being taught and how gifts are handled can help us make a responsible decision.

Some needs will be close enough for us to see ourselves. A struggling believer may need groceries or help keeping a home. A widow or an orphan may lack family support, while an exhausted household may need practical help that costs us time as well as money. Missionaries and persecuted Christians can need assistance beyond what their own communities can provide. The point is to pay attention to people, so that our giving answers a need we have taken the time to understand.

Church leaders should explain those needs honestly and give people room to respond before God. Promising wealth, healing, or special favor in exchange for a donation abuses that trust. So does twisting a passage to frighten someone into giving. People should know how their gift will be used, and they should be free to give it willingly.

I also have to be honest about the possibility that I am using an objection to coercion to hide my own greed. Saying that I do not owe a compulsory tenth does not answer whether I am willing to help anyone. A required percentage cannot cure a heart determined to keep everything else, and removing the percentage does not excuse that heart either. The New Testament directs me toward gratitude for God’s grace and love for the people He has placed within my reach.

God has shown us that grace through Jesus Christ. The eternal Son became truly human and willingly gave Himself to be slain as the perfect, sinless sacrifice for our sins. Wicked men tortured His innocent body and killed Him. His shed blood and death completed His saving sacrifice before His burial and bodily resurrection. The Father did not punish, curse, abandon, strike, bruise, or pour wrath on Jesus. Father and Son remained united in redemption.

We remember that finished sacrifice when we observe communion, sharing the bread and the cup in remembrance of His body and His blood. I cannot pay Christ back for what He has done, and I cannot use a gift to make Him give me whatever I want. I can respond to His grace by putting what He has entrusted to me at His service.

Christ died for the whole world and genuinely offers salvation to every person, although people can resist His offer. Everyone who repents and believes is forgiven and justified, meaning declared righteous before God. The believer is born again, and the Holy Spirit comes to dwell within him and seals him. His eternal life is secure because God is the One who saves.

That assurance does not permit lawlessness. A claim to be a Christian does not establish that someone has been born again, and the new life God gives should become evident in how we live. Generosity can grow from that new life, but it cannot purchase the salvation God gives freely.

My Final Thoughts

I do not believe Christians are required to continue Israel’s tithe system. Abram’s gift and Jacob’s vow did not establish a law for the church, and the commands concerning Israel’s tithes belonged to its covenant life and priesthood. The instructions given to believers call for planned, willing generosity according to our ability, with real support for ministry and people in need.

That leaves me responsible for more than defending a position about ten percent. I have to consider whether I am making room to help, whether I follow through when I say I will give, and whether my spending reflects the Lord’s claim on my life. I want to give because His grace has made me willing to care for others. Their needs should not be forgotten simply because I have established that I am free from Israel’s tithe law.