Calvinism Examined: Do the Five Points Match Scripture?

by Joshua Andreasen | Founder of Unforsaken

I believe Christ died for every person, that God genuinely calls sinners to repent and believe, and that everyone truly born again is eternally secure in Him. Those convictions are why I disagree with Calvinism, a system of teaching that connects salvation to God’s choice of particular people before creation. The disagreement is not over whether we need God’s grace. It is over how Scripture describes that grace reaching us and how we respond to it.

Calvinism and the Authority of Scripture

If you have heard someone refer to the five points of Calvinism, the word TULIP is a way of remembering their names. It stands for Total Depravity, Unconditional Election, Limited Atonement, Irresistible Grace, and Perseverance of the Saints. Each point contributes to an explanation of how God saves, so we need to understand what those names mean before examining the passages used to support them.

Total depravity teaches that sin has corrupted the whole person. Within the Calvinist system, it also means that a fallen person cannot believe in Christ until God first gives him spiritual life. That giving of life is called regeneration, or being born again. Unconditional election then identifies who receives that saving work: particular people whom God chose before creation, without making their foreseen faith or any other response a condition of His choice.

Limited atonement concerns the intention of Christ’s death. Also called definite atonement, it teaches that His death was intended to secure the salvation of the elect, meaning those chosen people. Irresistible grace describes God’s inward call that certainly brings them to faith. Perseverance of the saints teaches that those God regenerates will continue in faith to the end because He preserves them. Reformed teachers differ on some details, and these five points are not a summary of everything they believe, but they give us the claims being examined here.

The name Calvinism comes from John Calvin, a sixteenth-century Protestant Reformer. Calvin taught predestination, God’s determination of a person’s final destiny, and reprobation, His passing over or rejecting those not chosen for salvation. These questions did not begin with Calvin. Augustine, an earlier Christian bishop and writer, had addressed grace and predestination in his later writings, and Calvin drew on him in explaining his own position.

The five-point arrangement arose from a controversy after Calvin’s lifetime. Followers of Jacob Arminius, a Dutch theologian who disputed aspects of Reformed teaching, presented five articles in the Remonstrance of 1610. A church assembly called the Synod of Dort answered them in 1618–1619. Its decisions, known as the Canons of Dort, addressed election, Christ’s death, human corruption and conversion, and perseverance. The Reformed Church in America’s historical introduction explains that setting. Calvin did not create the English acronym TULIP, and we should not confuse that later summary with the whole of his teaching.

I do not think we prove or disprove Calvinism by proposing a chain of philosophical influences behind Augustine or Calvin. We need to examine what the doctrines actually say and then compare them with Scripture. I agree with the desire to honor God’s rule, take sin seriously, and leave no room for boasting about salvation. But agreeing with those concerns does not require me to accept every conclusion drawn from them.

Paul’s warning to the Colossian believers gives us a reason to keep that distinction in view. He had urged them to remain rooted in Christ rather than be deceived by persuasive words. Then he wrote:

Beware lest anyone cheat you through philosophy and empty deceit, according to the tradition of men, according to the basic principles of the world, and not according to Christ.

Colossians 2:8

Paul is warning about teaching that leads people away from Christ by making human tradition the authority. He is not telling us to stop thinking carefully or to avoid comparing passages. In the surrounding verses he directs attention to the fullness of God dwelling in Christ and to what believers have received in Him. I want that same attention to govern this study. If a theological definition causes me to narrow an invitation God gives, I need to return to the passage and examine why I am reading it that way (Colossians 2:1-15).

Sin, God’s Rule, and the Question of Ability

Before discussing what a sinner can or cannot do, I want to be clear about God’s authority. He knows the end from the beginning, and He accomplishes what He has purposed. He raises up rulers and removes them, restrains evil, answers prayer, and judges nations. Human resistance cannot force Him to abandon His final purpose or prevent Christ’s kingdom. I do not understand a genuine response to His grace to mean that God is uncertain about the future or dependent on our permission to rule (Isaiah 46:9-11; Daniel 2:20-22).

The question is whether that rule requires an unchangeable decree determining every sinful choice. The Westminster Confession, chapter 3, says that God ordains everything that happens, while also denying that He authors sin or forces the creature’s will. Those denials belong to the confession, and I should not misrepresent it. My disagreement concerns the claim that every event, including every sinful decision, must have been determined in that way.

Scripture describes people resisting what God commands and also describes Him governing what follows. Sometimes He restrains evil or directs its consequences toward His purpose. Sometimes He gives persistent rebels over to the course they have chosen. Romans 1, for example, describes people suppressing the truth and exchanging the worship of their Creator for idols. God’s judgment gives them over to the desires they have embraced. Their rebellion remains their own wrongdoing (Romans 1:18-32).

We can see God’s purpose and human responsibility together at the cross. In Acts 2, Peter is preaching in Jerusalem after Jesus’ resurrection. He tells his hearers that Jesus was delivered according to God’s determined purpose and foreknowledge, and in the same sentence he charges them with having Him crucified by lawless hands. God’s saving purpose did not turn those actions into innocent conduct (Acts 2:22-24).

Later, the believers pray about opposition to Jesus and name Herod and Pontius Pilate, the rulers involved, together with Gentiles and people from Israel. They acknowledge that God accomplished what He had determined beforehand. I do not read that prayer as making the Father the one who tortured or punished His Son. The hatred and violence belonged to the people who acted against Jesus, while God accomplished His saving purpose through Christ’s willing sacrifice (Acts 4:23-31).

Our response to Him is also possible only because He acts graciously toward us. We could not know His truth unless He revealed it. The gospel reaches us because He provides the message and sends people to preach it, and the Holy Spirit brings conviction concerning sin. Christ draws sinners to Himself. Receiving what God provides does not mean we created it or earned it. I understand His call to address people who can receive or resist the light He gives (John 16:7-11; Romans 10:14-17).

That does not minimize what sin has done. All people have sinned, and no one can justify himself before God. Sin corrupts our thinking and desires, and it damages our relationships. Adam, the first man, disobeyed God, and through that fall humanity inherited corruption and mortality. I understand us to be guilty for our own sins rather than inheriting Adam’s personal guilt. The distinction does not make us innocent or capable of repairing ourselves. We cannot remove our guilt, earn God’s acceptance, or give ourselves spiritual life (Romans 3:9-26; 5:12-21; Ezekiel 18:19-20).

The disagreement begins when total depravity is made to mean that God must regenerate someone before that person can believe. Calvinists ordinarily mean an order of dependence: regeneration produces faith. They do not necessarily mean that someone is born again and then waits a measurable period before believing. I understand the order differently. God graciously draws and enables a sinner through His truth, and the person who believes receives new life from Him.

Ephesians 2 is often central to that discussion because Paul describes the believers’ former condition as death in sin.

And you He made alive, who were dead in trespasses and sins, in which you once walked according to the course of this world, according to the prince of the power of the air, the spirit who now works in the sons of disobedience, among whom also we all once conducted ourselves in the lusts of our flesh, fulfilling the desires of the flesh and of the mind, and were by nature children of wrath, just as the others. But God, who is rich in mercy, because of His great love with which He loved us, even when we were dead in trespasses, made us alive together with Christ (by grace you have been saved),

Ephesians 2:1-5

The people Paul calls dead were walking according to the world and acting on sinful desires. Spiritual death is a real condition of separation from God and bondage to sin, but the description is not an instruction to apply every feature of a physical corpse to a sinner hearing God’s Word. If we assume that comparison proves a person must already have new life before he can believe, we have supplied a conclusion the passage still needs to establish.

Paul goes on to say that salvation is by grace through faith and that it leaves no room for boasting. God makes us alive with Christ; we do not accomplish that work ourselves. I find the passage consistent with a sinner receiving life through faith in the Savior, while depending entirely on God’s gracious action (Ephesians 2:8-10).

Jesus’ words in John 5 help explain why spiritual death does not make His call meaningless. He says that the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God and that those who hear will live. In the preceding verse He joins hearing His word and believing the Father with having everlasting life and passing from death into life. The power belongs to the Son and His word. I do not find Him saying that those hearers must already be born again before they can believe (John 5:24-25).

Paul also preached to people in Athens who were surrounded by idols. He introduced the God who made the world and gives everyone life and breath, then told them that God commands all people everywhere to repent because a day of judgment is coming. Some mocked, while others believed. I understand that command as a genuine call, made possible by what God reveals and provides, rather than an invitation to people who have no possibility of responding to His grace (Acts 17:16-34).

Creation bears witness to God, and conscience responds to moral truth, although neither our observation of creation nor our conscience can save us. We still need the Savior announced in the gospel. The help comes from God all the way through. He has no debt to repay us, but that does not make the light He gives or the call to repent insincere (Romans 1:19-20; 2:14-16).

Faith therefore gives me no achievement to boast about. In Romans 4:1-5, Paul compares wages owed to a worker with righteousness received through believing God. A worker can claim payment for work performed; a sinner trusting Christ is depending on mercy he has not earned. When I believe, I abandon the attempt to save myself and receive the Savior God supplied. I did not provide the cross, produce the truth, or create eternal life.

Election in Christ and Romans 9

The next point, unconditional election, concerns God’s choice before creation. Calvinism teaches that He selected particular fallen people for salvation without making foreseen faith a condition of that choice, and that He gives those people the call that certainly produces faith. I reject that explanation, but I do not reject election itself. Scripture teaches that God chooses. The question in each passage is whom He chooses and what He chooses them for.

For example, God chose Israel to be His covenant people, the nation to whom He gave particular promises and responsibilities. He appointed Aaron and his sons to serve as priests, and He chose David to become king over Israel. Jesus chose twelve disciples to serve as apostles, His commissioned messengers. A choice for a national role or a particular service does not automatically tell us how an individual receives salvation (Deuteronomy 7:6-8; Exodus 28:1; 1 Samuel 16:1-13; Luke 6:12-16).

Scripture also identifies Christ Himself as God’s chosen Servant. Peter describes Him as a chosen cornerstone, using the image of the principal stone around which a building is formed. So when Paul speaks about believers being chosen, I want to pay attention to where he places them in relation to Christ (Isaiah 42:1; 1 Peter 2:4-6).

just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before Him in love, having predestined us to adoption as sons by Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the good pleasure of His will, to the praise of the glory of His grace, by which He made us accepted in the Beloved.

Ephesians 1:4-6

Paul says that God chose us in Him. He is describing people united to Christ, and the purpose he names is that they should be holy and without blame. Their adoption as God’s children also comes through Jesus Christ. As the paragraph continues, Paul explains that redemption comes through His blood, that the inheritance belongs to God’s purpose in Him, and that God will gather all things together in Christ (Ephesians 1:3-12).

I understand this to describe God’s eternal plan for a people who belong to His Son. Their future was not an improvised response to human failure. Before the foundation of the world, God determined what His people would receive in Christ and what they would become. The repeated emphasis on being in Him keeps the Son at the center of the choice.

Paul then addresses how the Ephesians came to share in those blessings. They heard the word of truth, believed in Christ, and were sealed with the Holy Spirit. A seal identifies them as belonging to God, and Paul calls the Spirit the guarantee of their inheritance. Calvinists distinguish this sealing from regeneration, so I would not treat those terms as interchangeable. But the sealing Paul describes follows faith, and these verses do not establish an earlier regeneration that made faith possible. I read the sequence as consistent with receiving life through faith in Christ (Ephesians 1:13-14).

Romans 8:29 also tells us what God predestined for those He foreknew: they would be conformed to the image of His Son. Predestined means that He determined their destiny beforehand. The stated destiny is to become like Christ. Peter likewise connects election with the Father’s foreknowledge and the Spirit’s work of setting people apart, together with obedience and the blood of Jesus Christ. These are descriptions of God’s purpose for His people, not grounds for making His invitation to others insincere (1 Peter 1:1-2).

In 2 Thessalonians 2:13-14, Paul joins God’s choice for salvation with the Spirit’s sanctifying work and belief in the truth. He then says that God called these believers through the gospel. Sanctification is God’s work of setting people apart for Himself. I do not separate that work from belief in order to turn the passage into a decree that excludes other hearers from a genuine opportunity to receive Christ. God knows every person and event, and He has established the destiny of those who are in His Son.

Romans 9 raises a related question through Israel’s history. Paul begins by grieving for his fellow Israelites. They had received the covenants and the Law, and Jesus came from their people according to His human ancestry. Yet many rejected Him. Paul is answering whether their unbelief means God’s word has failed.

He begins with Abraham’s family. Abraham had sons named Ishmael and Isaac, but the promised family line continued through Isaac. Isaac and his wife Rebekah then had twin sons, Esau and Jacob. Paul points to what God said about those children before either had been born.

And not only this, but when Rebecca also had conceived by one man, even by our father Isaac (for the children not yet being born, nor having done any good or evil, that the purpose of God according to election might stand, not of works but of Him who calls), it was said to her, "The older shall serve the younger." As it is written, "Jacob I have loved, but Esau I have hated." What shall we say then? Is there unrighteousness with God? Certainly not! For He says to Moses, "I will have mercy on whomever I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whomever I will have compassion." So then it is not of him who wills, nor of him who runs, but of God who shows mercy. For the Scripture says to the Pharaoh, "For this very purpose I have raised you up, that I may show My power in you, and that My name may be declared in all the earth." Therefore He has mercy on whom He wills, and whom He wills He hardens.

Romans 9:10-18

To show you why I read this in its national and covenant setting, let’s compare Paul’s quotations with the passages he is using. In Genesis 25:21-23, Rebekah asks the Lord about the children struggling within her. God answers that two nations are in her womb and that the older will serve the younger. The descendants of Jacob became Israel, and the descendants of Esau became Edom. God was choosing the line through which His covenant promises would continue before either son had done anything to earn that place.

The words concerning love for Jacob and hatred for Esau come from Malachi 1:1-5, centuries after the brothers lived. Malachi addresses Israel, and the Lord points to Edom’s devastated territory in describing His judgment. These are nations with a history. I do not understand Paul to be turning those passages into an announcement that one infant was destined for salvation and the other for damnation regardless of any genuine response to God.

Paul’s next quotation, about God’s mercy, comes from His conversation with Moses after Israel made a golden calf and worshiped it. Moses was the leader through whom God had brought the people out of Egypt, and he pleaded for them after their rebellion. God spoke of His freedom to show compassion. Israel could not demand mercy as wages for good conduct, because its conduct deserved judgment (Exodus 32:1-14; 33:12-19).

Pharaoh, the ruler of Egypt, provides Paul’s example of hardening. Before Israel made that calf, Pharaoh had held the Israelites in bondage and refused God’s command to release them. When Moses and Aaron brought that command, he increased the people’s burdens. During the plagues, he repeatedly refused to listen, and Exodus expressly says that he hardened his heart when relief came (Exodus 5:1-9; 8:15, 32).

Exodus also says that the Lord hardened Pharaoh’s heart. I understand that as judicial hardening: God’s judgment confirming a persistent rebel in the course he has chosen. God displayed His power through His dealings with that ruler and brought His people out despite Pharaoh’s resistance. This was not a humble man asking to trust the Lord and being prevented from doing so. Nor should we remove God’s action from the account. The text records both Pharaoh’s guilt and the Lord’s judgment (Exodus 7:1-5; 9:12-17, 34-35).

Paul then uses the image of a potter with authority over his clay. The Creator has the right to judge His creatures. But that image does not require us to erase the response God calls for. In Jeremiah 18, the Lord sends Jeremiah to watch a potter remake a marred vessel. He applies the picture to nations and says that if a nation warned of judgment turns from evil, He will relent from the announced disaster. God’s authority and a call to turn from sin appear together.

By the end of Romans 9, Paul explains why Israel stumbled: the people sought righteousness by works rather than by faith, and they stumbled over Christ. In Romans 10, he prays for their salvation and tells his hearers to believe. His invitation is as broad as the words he quotes.

For the Scripture says, "Whoever believes on Him will not be put to shame." For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek, for the same Lord over all is rich to all who call upon Him. For "whoever calls on the name of the LORD shall be saved."

Romans 10:11-13

Paul does not tell the hearer to discover a hidden decree before calling on the Lord. He says that whoever believes will not be put to shame. The chapter closes with God stretching out His hands to a disobedient people, and Romans 11 explicitly denies that He has cast Israel away. Its hardening is partial and temporary, and Paul continues to speak of its future within God’s purpose (Romans 10:21; 11:1-2, 25-29).

Gentiles, people from outside Israel, receive salvation through faith, while those who refuse Christ remain accountable for their unbelief. I read these chapters as affirming God’s freedom to fulfill His promises and judge rebellion, without canceling the hearer’s responsibility to believe. They also preserve His promises to Israel. Bringing Gentiles into His saving purpose does not mean the church has replaced Israel and erased that nation’s future.

Christ Died for the Whole World

The question of whom God chooses leads to the third point: for whom did Christ die? Definite atonement distinguishes the value of His sacrifice from its intended saving effect. The second head of the Canons of Dort affirms that His death is sufficient for the world while teaching that it effectually redeems the elect. My objection is not that Calvinists assign too little value to His blood. It is that they restrict the intended saving provision to people selected beforehand.

Paul’s instruction to Timothy gives me a different understanding of that provision. Timothy was a fellow minister to whom Paul gave guidance for the church. In 1 Timothy 2, Paul begins by urging prayer for all people, including kings and others in authority. He then explains why those prayers agree with God’s desire.

Therefore I exhort first of all that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks be made for all men, for kings and all who are in authority, that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and reverence. For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Savior, who desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth. For there is one God and one Mediator between God and men, the Man Christ Jesus, who gave Himself a ransom for all, to be testified in due time,

1 Timothy 2:1-6

Notice the connection between the prayer and the reason Paul gives for it. We are to pray for all because God desires all to be saved, and because Christ gave Himself as a ransom for all. A ransom is a price paid for release; here Jesus gave Himself. He is also the one Mediator, the One through whom sinful people can be reconciled to God.

The reference to rulers has sometimes been used to interpret all as all classes of people rather than every person. I understand Paul to be making sure rulers are included in the prayers, not reducing the reach of God’s saving desire. He gives the broad command, includes people in authority, and then points to Christ’s giving of Himself for all. I do not find a reason in that argument to limit the provision to a previously selected group.

Other passages lead me to the same conclusion. Hebrews 2:9 says that Jesus tasted death for everyone. John the Baptist, the messenger who prepared people for Jesus’ coming, identified Him as the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. Then the apostle John, writing to believers, expressly distinguishes their sins from those of the whole world (John 1:29).

My little children, these things I write to you, so that you may not sin. And if anyone sins, we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous. And He Himself is the propitiation for our sins, and not for ours only but also for the whole world.

1 John 2:1-2

John calls Jesus our Advocate, the One who represents believers before the Father when they sin. He also calls Him the propitiation for sin, meaning the atoning sacrifice through whom sin is dealt with before God. John says that sacrifice concerns our sins and also the sins of the whole world. I do not understand him to mean only believers scattered throughout the world, because his wording deliberately reaches beyond the believers he has just addressed.

Peter adds another detail when he warns that false teachers will bring destructive teaching into the church. He says they will deny the Lord who bought them and bring destruction upon themselves. I understand that warning to be inconsistent with restricting Christ’s purchase to those who will certainly be saved (2 Peter 2:1-3).

That does not mean everyone is saved. Universalism, the belief that all people finally receive salvation, is different from saying Christ provided salvation for all. John 3:16-18 joins God’s love for the world with the promise of life to the believer, while also saying that the unbeliever remains condemned. The provision is for the world; its saving benefit is received through faith.

The sufficiency of this sacrifice rests in who Jesus is and what He gave. He is the eternal Son, fully God, who became fully man and was born of a virgin. He lived without sin. Wicked men tortured and crucified Him, while He voluntarily gave Himself to be slain as the perfect sacrifice for our sins. His saving work through His shed blood and death was complete before He was buried and rose bodily from the dead (John 1:1-14; Luke 1:26-38; John 10:17-18; 19:30; 1 Corinthians 15:3-4).

I do not understand His sacrifice as the Father punishing, cursing, abandoning, striking, bruising, or pouring wrath upon Jesus. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit remained united, with no broken fellowship in the Godhead. Christ’s perfection and His willing death provide what sinners could never provide for themselves. We can offer every person salvation through the blood of this crucified and risen Savior.

Grace Can Be Resisted and Christ Draws All

If Christ provided salvation for all, why do some people refuse Him? The fourth point of Calvinism answers by distinguishing two calls. The outward call is the preaching of the gospel, which people can resist. The inward effectual call is given to the elect and certainly brings them to faith. Effectual means that it accomplishes the intended result.

The third and fourth heads of Dort affirm a sincere gospel invitation and describe God renewing a person’s will so that he willingly responds. Irresistible grace therefore does not mean forcing a person to come to Christ while leaving his desires unchanged. It means God’s inward work certainly changes those desires and produces belief. I disagree that Scripture establishes a saving call restricted in that way.

Stephen’s words in Acts 7 show people resisting the Holy Spirit. Stephen was a believer in Jesus defending his witness before the religious council in Jerusalem. He had recounted Israel’s history and the repeated rejection of God’s messengers. He then confronted his hearers with their part in that same refusal.

"You stiff-necked and uncircumcised in heart and ears! You always resist the Holy Spirit; as your fathers did, so do you. Which of the prophets did your fathers not persecute? And they killed those who foretold the coming of the Just One, of whom you now have become the betrayers and murderers, who have received the law by the direction of angels and have not kept it."

Acts 7:51-53

The Just One Stephen names is Jesus, whom the prophets had foretold. He charges his hearers with resisting the Spirit and rejecting the One those prophets announced. Their response was to stop their ears, rush at him, take him outside the city, and stone him to death. The account gives us an actual refusal of God’s witness, not simply an abstract question about what resistance might mean (Acts 7:54-60).

Jesus also grieved over Jerusalem after rebuking leaders who followed their ancestors in rejecting God’s messengers. He said He had wanted to gather the city’s children as a hen gathers her chicks, but they were unwilling. In John 5, He told people who searched the Scriptures that those Scriptures testified about Him, yet they would not come to Him to receive life. Their refusal was the problem He identified (Matthew 23:29-39; John 5:39-40).

Luke records a similar refusal in response to John the Baptist. Many people had received John’s baptism, but the Pharisees and lawyers, religious leaders and teachers of the Law, had refused it. Luke describes them as rejecting God’s will for themselves. Proverbs 1 presents the same responsibility through the picture of wisdom calling openly and being refused. The people being warned despise the counsel offered to them (Luke 7:24-30; Proverbs 1:20-33).

The Calvinist distinction between an outward call and an irresistible inward call is often offered as the answer to these passages. But naming that distinction does not establish that the people described were denied a genuine opportunity to respond to God’s gracious work. I understand His invitations and rebukes to express a real desire for them to come. He initiates and supplies what their response requires, while their refusal remains their own.

Acts 13 also requires us to take God’s action seriously. Paul and Barnabas were preaching in a synagogue, where people gathered to hear the Scriptures, and their message drew a large crowd on the following Sabbath. Some opponents became envious and contradicted Paul. He and Barnabas told them that they were rejecting the Word and judging themselves unworthy of everlasting life. When the Gentiles heard the message of salvation reaching them, they rejoiced, and Luke says that as many as had been appointed to eternal life believed (Acts 13:38-48).

I accept what Luke says about that appointment. I do not need to rewrite it into a statement that the people appointed themselves. But I also cannot use the statement about those who believed to cancel what the same account says about those who refused. They were addressed with the Word and held responsible for rejecting it. God’s work in salvation and their accountability both belong to the account.

John 6 brings us directly to the Father’s drawing. Jesus says that no one can come to Him unless the Father draws him. That rules out any explanation in which a sinner comes independently of God’s help. Before drawing a further conclusion about whom He draws, let’s read the promise Jesus gives in that same discussion.

"All that the Father gives Me will come to Me, and the one who comes to Me I will by no means cast out. For I have come down from heaven, not to do My own will, but the will of Him who sent Me. This is the will of the Father who sent Me, that of all He has given Me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up at the last day. And this is the will of Him who sent Me, that everyone who sees the Son and believes in Him may have everlasting life; and I will raise him up at the last day."

John 6:37-40

Jesus says that all the Father gives Him will come and that He will not cast out the one who comes. He also promises to preserve those given to Him and raise them at the last day. I believe those promises. They tell me that receiving life from Christ ends in resurrection, not in His losing someone He undertook to keep.

Jesus connects coming with believing, and in verse 45 He explains that everyone who has heard and learned from the Father comes to Him. So I read the statement about drawing alongside His words about hearing, learning, and believing. The Father must draw; we cannot leave that out. But Jesus does not say here that the Father first regenerates selected people before they believe. I do not think the passage requires the Calvinist explanation of how His drawing works (John 6:35, 44-47).

Later in John’s Gospel, some Greeks came seeking Jesus shortly before His crucifixion. In that setting, Jesus spoke about His approaching death and the reach of His drawing. The arrival of people from outside Israel helps us hear the breadth of what He says.

"Now is the judgment of this world; now the ruler of this world will be cast out. And I, if I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all peoples to Myself." This He said, signifying by what death He would die.

John 12:31-33

John explains that being lifted up refers to the death Jesus would die. His drawing is connected to the cross, and He speaks of drawing all peoples to Himself. I understand that to extend beyond Israel and beyond a hidden group chosen for salvation. It does not mean everyone is finally saved, because the same Gospel records people refusing the light and remaining in unbelief. Christ acts first in drawing sinners, and those who refuse Him remain responsible (John 12:20-43).

Lydia’s conversion shows God’s gracious action in a particular person’s life. In Acts 16, Paul and his companions went to a place of prayer beside a river at Philippi and spoke to the women gathered there. Lydia, a seller of purple from Thyatira who worshiped God, listened. The Lord opened her heart to heed Paul’s message, and she and her household were baptized (Acts 16:11-15).

I gladly affirm that the Lord opened her heart. The account does not say that she was born again before believing, nor does it tell us that the other women were denied grace. I understand God to be enabling her through the truth she heard and Lydia to be responding to that truth. Recognizing her response takes nothing away from the One who made it possible.

Eternal Security Without Calvinism

The final point, perseverance of the saints, concerns what happens to those who have been saved. Calvinism teaches that those truly elected, called, and regenerated will be preserved and continue in faith to the end. I agree that everyone truly born again is eternally secure. That agreement does not establish the other four points or require me to accept their explanation of how a person comes to Christ.

When someone repents and believes in Jesus, God justifies that person, declaring him righteous, and gives him new birth. He really becomes a new creation. The Holy Spirit, who is a divine Person, indwells him and seals him as belonging to God. Eternal life does not become temporary whenever a believer fails. Jesus explained His keeping of His people when He was asked in the temple to say plainly whether He was the Christ, God’s promised Savior (John 10:24-30).

"But you do not believe, because you are not of My sheep, as I said to you. My sheep hear My voice, and I know them, and they follow Me. And I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; neither shall anyone snatch them out of My hand. My Father, who has given them to Me, is greater than all; and no one is able to snatch them out of My Father's hand. I and My Father are one."

John 10:26-30

Jesus describes His sheep as people who hear His voice and follow Him, and He promises that they will never perish. Their security rests in His care and in the Father’s power. Paul likewise identifies the Holy Spirit as the guarantee of the believer’s inheritance. God does not merely attach a religious label that He removes whenever His child stumbles. He gives new life and keeps the person who belongs to Him (Ephesians 1:13-14).

That promise does not turn every profession of faith into proof of new birth. John wrote about people who had departed from the believers and denied the truth about Christ. He said their departure showed that they had never truly belonged. A person can claim a connection to Christ without having received the life He gives (1 John 2:18-23).

Nor does security give God’s children permission to continue in lawlessness. Hebrews 12 describes a Father who corrects His children for their good, so that they share in His holiness. Believers still need that correction because new birth does not make them sinlessly perfect. Their obedience should show the life God has given them, but it does not purchase salvation or keep it from expiring. God works in His children because they belong to Him (Hebrews 12:5-11; Ephesians 2:8-10).

I also want to be precise about assurance, our confidence that we are saved. The Westminster Confession, chapter 18, points to God’s promises, the Spirit’s testimony, and inward evidence of grace. It would be inaccurate to say that the confession rests assurance on performance alone. My concern is with teaching that leaves someone continually measuring his perseverance to discover whether he was secretly chosen.

When a believer struggles, I want to direct him first to Christ’s promise and completed work, together with the Spirit’s seal. Growth in obedience belongs in the Christian life, and Scripture gives us reason to examine whether a profession is genuine. But obedience is not the foundation holding salvation in place. The Savior who gave eternal life is the One who keeps His people.

Rejecting Calvinism does not force me to accept forms of Arminian teaching that allow salvation to be lost. A person can resist Christ’s call before being saved, yet once genuinely born again, he belongs to the One who promises never to lose His sheep. I can accept both the genuine invitation and the lasting security without treating either promise as an embarrassment to be explained away.

God knows every person and every event. He established His saving plan in Christ, and He guarantees the final destiny of everyone who belongs to His Son. His rule over nations and His judgment of hardened rebellion do not require me to deny a genuine response to grace. The sinner cannot manufacture salvation; God supplies the Savior, brings the truth, convicts through His Spirit, and makes that response possible.

That is why I can offer the gospel to every person without wondering whether Christ made provision for the one listening. If Calvinism has left you afraid that He may not have died for you, return to the words we have examined. Jesus tasted death for everyone. God desires all people to be saved, and the one Mediator gave Himself as a ransom for all. You do not need access to a hidden decree before you repent and believe in Him.

Believing Him does not make salvation your accomplishment. God sent His Son, Christ shed His blood and died for our sins, and God raised Him from the dead. You could not do those things or give yourself eternal life. Even the saving message came from Him. Faith receives what He provides, so gratitude belongs to God rather than to the person receiving His mercy.

If you are born again, His assurance also gives you reason to receive His correction instead of hiding from it. The Shepherd keeps His sheep, and the Spirit who seals you works to make you holy. I cannot honestly appeal to the Savior’s faithfulness as an excuse to disregard Him. I can rest in His care while turning from the sin His Word exposes.

My Final Thoughts

I do not find the five points of Calvinism to be a faithful explanation of the passages we have examined. God’s choice has to be understood in the setting of each passage, Christ’s saving provision reaches the whole world, and His gracious work can be resisted. None of that gives a sinner the ability to save himself or a reason to boast. God provides what we receive through faith.

I also find that Christ’s promise to keep His people gives us a firm place to rest. Everyone truly born again belongs to the Savior who shed His blood and died, was buried, and rose bodily. I do not need to discover a hidden decree or make the strength of my performance the foundation of His promise. I can trust Him, proclaim His invitation to others, and receive His correction as someone He has made His own.